Question about viola and the Alto clef?

Question

This is purely out of curiosity, since I can't read music. (Actually, I can read music, in a hunt and peck fashion, but can't sight read, so I only play by ear)

I understand how the Alto clef fits into the grand clef and the reason it was originally used to write for the viola. But, given that its lowest note is an octave C below Middle C, wouldn't it be far simpler to use the Treble clef, since the lowest note on the clef would coincide with the lowest open note on the viola? I realize everything would sound an octave lower, but that really wouldn't matter in the final outcome, would it?

What am I missing?

lainiebsky · Accepted Answer

In treble clef, the first octave on viola requires ledger lines.  That's quite cumbersome.

You know that middle C is below the staff in treble clef, right?  That puts a whole octave on viola on those ledger lines.  It's far easier to use alto clef, in which most of the notes are comfortably on the staff.  Treble clef is used for high passages, which works out just fine.

Anonymous · Answer

Don't cellists read the Treble clef, playing two octaves lower, when they transcribe violin pieces?

Mamianka · Answer

" I realize everything would sound an octave lower, but that really wouldn't matter in the final outcome, would it? "

Yep - THAT'S what you are missing.  It's WRONG.  Period.  Why should the whole world have to adapt, just because some people are TOO LAZY to do things right?  It's hard enough to make things clear - but to actually do it WRONG, and then tell them, essentially, to just deal with it, does not make it any better.

Trending News

Question about viola and the Alto clef?

3 Answers