Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Any experience with extreme power line networking?

I'm looking for some "real world" experience with Ethernet-over-AC-powerline devices.

I'm trying to deliver Internet to an outbuilding on a farm. The outbuilding is maybe 150 feet line-of-sight from the Wi-Fi router, but masonry and steel walls kill that signal. So I'm considering a powerline networking kit.

The AC wire path from the router to the outbuilding is close to 200 feet, mostly in underground conduit. BUT: the signal would pass through three subpanels, as well as the farm main panelboard. If the signal is riding the "hot" (black) wire, it might pass through six circuit breakers.

No transformers, at least.

This is a lot more demanding than the typical application for a powerline networking kit. Before I spend money on a kit, does it stand any chance of working?

Update:

Thanks for the thoughtful answers.

I've already got "Ethernet to second switch and WAP" serving another part of the property. That would be my first choice for this outbuilding, as well. But there's a paved driveway to cross. I can't trench it, and an aerial run would have to be high enough to clear semis and "Max Max"-looking farm equipment.

"Ethernet to wireless point-to-point bridge" would work, as long as I can protect the exterior antennas from storm and snow. But it's costly.

Update 2:

Again, thanks for the solid answers, all around. I'll probably be best off pulling an Ethernet cable the length of the main building, and using a wireless bridge for the final hop, across the paved driveways.

4 Answers

Relevance
  • 5 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    They usually work very well.

    Get the highest speed ones you can find, with gigabit ethernet ports.

    The actual connection speed depends on signal strength, so if you are only getting 30% speed due to the distance, 30% or 1200Mbit is rather better than 30% of 200Mbit.

    Circuit breakers should have little effect but any "mains suppressors" or filtered outlets / cables may kill the signal.

    Things that just have lightning or "spike" suppression should have no effect but any capacitive noise filter will drastically weaken it.

    Laying an Ethernet cable is actually the best solution, if that is possible.

    Ethernet is specified to perform at the rated speed of the connected ports (eg. gigabit) over at least 100m, which is way more than your 150ft path.

    You can add an ethernet switch in the building to distribute it to however many computer etc. you need, plus a WiFi access point (_not_ router) to give WiFi in that area.

    If you set that with exactly the same name & password as the existing setup but on a different channel (out of 1, 6 & 11) any WiFi gear will "roam" between the two, using whichever is strongest.

    The same setup would work via the powerline link, though possibly with limited speeds.

  • Adrian
    Lv 7
    5 years ago

    I have my doubts it will work. Too many panels. Ethernet over powerline is conducted by the wires, and panels and breakers cause the signal to "not" pass thru wires, but general distribution panels. That will weaken any signal. Also, the distances are rather limited as well, even over good wiring. Going 200ft via house wiring may attenuate the signal significantly (then add on the problem of the extra panels). Finally, the signal should be on the same "phase" (same side of the 120/240 circuit). Going through breakers makes it hard to ensure the signal is on the same side as the next breaker (feeding towards the next location).

    Thus, I would say not likely. If you want a reliable signal, either use fiber optic cable (Ethernet to fiber converters) or a wireless bridge. There are semi-commercial wireless bridges, with external dishes/antennas, that can provide 100Mbps across several hundred feet with clear line of sight. Even in my case, I have a simple wireless bridge running up to 72Mbps about 400ft through a few trees with no problems. Get someone who knows how to set up a wireless bridge to help you... Wireless bridges cost about $100 for each end, better ones $150 (but $100 bridges should work ok).

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    HI Forget it this system is just so useless a wifi with an external antenna would be the best idea so it needs both antennas pointing at each other ti work either 2.4ghz or 5.2 ghz.

  • Andy T
    Lv 7
    5 years ago

    Used Ethernet over AC before, but at a home setting so I have doubt in your wiring, so many panels it may degrade too much. Wi-Fi extender would be a better idea. In my trial Ethernet over AC it even degraded below current Wi-Fi 802.11n speed.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.