Are the MTB cycling shoes with the sneaker/jogging shoe appearance generally softer and less stiffer than the more traditional MTB shoe?

It really depends on the shoe.

I've tried some cross-over biking/hiking shoes that felt very reliable stiff and sturdy. But I've also tried some that were more like dual-use sneakers.

These didn't work out too well and split across the sole right behind the cleat while there was still plenty of life left in the rest of the shoe.

I generally use shoes easily identifiable as bike shoes. Its usually easy enough to figure out that I ride bicycles anyhow, so no point in being shy about it.

In general...yes. Giro makes some called "Grynd". Not misspelled. http://www.giro.com/us_en/grynd-20.html I use them strictly for platform pedals leaving the plate right where it came from the factory. I did NOT install SPD cleats.

The sad part is...if I had installed cleats, they would stick out too far. In other words, the space for the cleats is not recessed enough to make walking comfortable. It would also scratch floors. They're great for platform pedals. Not so much for Shimano or other brands of clip-in style MTB pedals.

You have to try them on MTB shoes are made to be flexible so you can walk in them they will pretty much have the same plate in them to support your foot. Road bike shoes will have the whole sole stiff for better support and they are not made for walking.

https://www.rei.com/learn/expert-advice/cycling-sh...

zaq