Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
When light changes to one medium to another does it change speed instantaneously or does it slow down/speed up very quickly. Please explain.?
Update: Maybe it would help if I explained why I'm asking this question. I'm writing a philosophy paper on the law of continuity (i.e. things don't make 'jumps', rather they pass through all intermediate states when going from one state to another) and I'm trying to find a counterexample in nature. With intention, then, I'm wondering whether light changing speeds as it changes medium is an example of a violation of the (supposed) law of continuity. If not, might anyone know of any?
6 Answers
- MorningfoxLv 74 years ago
It changes speed in just one molecular layer. So not "instantaneously", but faster than just "very quickly". Basically, the speed changes in a few times 10^-18 seconds.
============
You're going to have problems with this "law of continuity" when it comes down to quantum physics. In the real universe that we live in, there are some things that happen instantaneously. Not just in 10^-21 seconds, but actually in an instant. There are continuity conditions in quantum physics, but there are also some instantaneous actions. Such as quantum tunneling inside atoms, or non-local entanglement.
- oldprofLv 74 years ago
The photons do not change speed. They always scoot along at the speed of light in a vacuum...C.
So why the refraction index n = C/c; where c < C is the speed of light through a medium other than a vacuum?
c is not the speed of the photons when they are moving within the medium. It's the average speed c = S/T where S is the distance within the medium and the total time to make that distance is T.
But here's the deal. That total time includes the travel time when the photons are free to move about and the dwell time when the photons are coupled with the electrons bound to the atoms of the medium.
So if S is through a vacuum, we have C = S/t. But when those photons are captured and then next generation ones are released, that takes time, dwell time, dt. So depending on how often photons couple and decouple we have the total dwell time SUM(dt) that we have to add on to the vacuum travel time to get the total time T = t + SUM(dt) > t.
And that means c = S/T < S/t = C on average.
And this explains why reflected photons and photons that pass on through S exit the medium at exactly C, the speed of light in a vacuum. They never slowed down.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- ToddLv 74 years ago
Since it has no mass, it changes immediately. For electromagnetic waves/particles, there is no such thing as acceleration or deceleration.