Gift Ideas for Boyfriends Birthday?

So, my boyfriends birthday is coming up in a little less than a month now, and i’m really not sure what to get him. This is the first birthday since we’ve started dating so it’s my job to kind of “set the expectations” for our relationship. He insists that he doesn’t want me going out and buying him anything too much, but I do want to get him something small at least, even if it’s home-made. He’s turning 17, and i’m only 16, so please keep that in mind! I was thinking maybe making a memory box of us (we’ve been friends for a while before we dated) but i feel like that’s very “anniversary” and not so much “birthday”. Any other ideas for cute gifts? Home-made or not?