What is the immigration issue really about?

1. Securing our borders

2. Protecting American jobs

3. Racism and Xenophobia

2007-12-20T05:34:48Z

Thank you everyone for confirming what I thought... that politicians are using fear to mislead us.

If this issue was about security, politicians would be talking about the even larger unprotected border to our North. Then again, Canadians are white, so they don't. Or they would be talking about our unprotected ports which is an even more important problem that needs to be solved.

And any economist would tell you we desperately need a guest worker problem and "just throwing them out" would send us into recession. A guest worker program is one of the few sensible solutions offered, but it has lost out to fear-mongering.

I'm not saying that border security isn't a real issue. And illegal immigration is unfair to those who want to come here legally.

But the issue, as currently defined by the politicians running for office, is clearly a "Willie Horton" issue. They are using race and hatred to get votes and it is despicable.

Bob G2007-12-17T13:49:20Z

Favorite Answer

2.

Right now, globalism is creating some kind of transition in the US economy. Overall, a global free market is good for the US economy, but it means change for quite a few people, and not necessarily change for the good.

Historically, any time the average American feels uncertain about their own economic aspects, anti-immigration sentiments rise.

nothing2007-12-17T21:45:08Z

1 and 2

tnfarmgirl2007-12-17T21:48:33Z

That would be 1 and 2.

Scott H2007-12-17T21:50:55Z

It is about some pols needing an issue to get people riled up getting votes. The one thing I am almost sure of, four years from now there will be more illegals, or undocumented, call them what you want, in the USA , than there are today.

Anonymous2007-12-17T21:46:58Z

I agree with the first answer.

Especially when we get into offering illegal aliens, health benefits, SS benefits, etc. There's a system. Go by it, become a citizen, then enjoy.

Edit: except the "killing Americans" part. We've got plenty of Americans, immigrants, and everyone else killing Americans. I don't think it needs to be pointed out specifically about illegal aliens.

Show more answers (10)