Is it okay for Paula & Randy to laugh a American Idol contestants?

The contestant was horrible and I was embarrassed for the poor guy. The Idol screeners let him get through to the the big three so everyone could all get a good laugh. Do you think that is wrong?

2008-01-15T17:30:44Z

Sorry. That should be laugh at....

ms.undrstd2008-01-15T17:30:24Z

Favorite Answer

no, because they know when they go on american idol that they can't sing so they go to be laughed at so they can get they're 2min. of fame!

Anonymous2008-01-15T22:12:24Z

I don't think any of them have the right to laugh at the contestants. I hate the way Simon Cowell puts some of them down and than last year he made fun of some guys looks also. I am not a fan of that show but occasionally I will watch it for a few minutes here and there.

PS Simon and Randy are not all that handsome themselves and Paula is just weird.

Rick F2008-01-15T17:30:56Z

When you sign up for it you kinda know what you're getting into. It doesn't make it right that they laugh... they need to put themselves in that person's shoes... but they don't care. They are rich and famous. But I am sure it is really, really hard not to laugh at some of the contestants who have no business being there.

happyreagan772008-01-15T17:30:51Z

the people audition/go on the show already knowing the risk of being laughed at, shown on tv, made fun of forever, and everything else! while it can be kinda sad for the contestants sometimes... paula and randy can't help what they consider to be funny... :)

Katers2008-01-15T17:31:21Z

I think that no matter how ridiculous these people are, Paula and Randy and Simon shouldn't be so mean. God says that we are supposed to love each other.
I think some of these contestants set themselves up for criticism though...

Show more answers (27)