If u were a contestant on American Idol and could pick one judge to judge u, would u pick-Randy, Paula,Simon?

Speaking of that, why is it that people are letting three random people tell them if they are a good singer or not? Can Paula, Randy, or Simon sing? I mean, c'mon...a washed up 80s pop singer judging talent?? Yikes, I would rather be judged by Luciano Pavarotti or Celine Dion...

BUT...From the one time I watched it, it seemed like Paula had no opinion of her own and she just smiled everytime and said that it was great. Simon complained, and Randy seems to give constructive criticism...I guess Randy's advice would be the most worthwhile...

Man, how long has this show been on now...?

Paula

Paula because I really suck and I already know it. No reason to have Simon spell it out for me!

well Paula is the best judge to pick, Simon not a chance,Randy he's ooook

Paula because she's always supportive and I would probably win.

Definitely not Simon, though he's my favorite because he's honest about it.

I would truthfully pick Simon. I know everyone hates him but I think he is very honest and if I were on the show I wouldn't want someone sugar coating their judgments. That way i could learn to get better.

you already know, that's a tremendous question! consistent with danger all 4 of them will %. a music mutually, or 2 ought to connect, like consistent with danger kara and paula ought to %. for Danny, Simon possibilities for Adam, and Randy possibilities for Kris. yet i've got have been given no clue.

I would choose Simon because he is honest. His ears can honestly filter out the bad talent from the good talent and his mouth speaks the truth! It also helps that he's got this cute British accent and he has a good sense of fashion.

=)

Well Paula is very sweet and I can't stand Randy but I think Simon is honest and I think he is HOT!!

Randy - because he's honest but cool about it. Paula may be too sweet, I would want a real critique. Simon can just be cruel.