8 hours left...Lets make our own poll...who should win American Idol?? Katharine or Tayler????????????????????

I agree Kat should win. Taylor is a great singer, but Kat fills the image and talent of an american idol. I absolutly loved somewhere over the rainbow. No matter who wins they will both get record contracts. my vote goes to Kat!!!!!!!!!

I say SOUL PATROl all the way! Kat can sing any song out there I will give you that, but she doesn't do it well. She puts no feeling into any song I have heard her sing. She is to worried about where the camera is. I think she should be on broadway, or in movies that way she can focus on the camera. Although I think you'd have to show compassion, and emotion acting so maybe that's not the best thing for her.

I think Taylor will win and will be a huge star!

SOUL PATROL SOUL PATROL!!!!

Based on the final performances, I think Taylor should win. I'm a huge Katharine fan too, but I think Taylor will win.

Kat has acted FAKE the last couple of weeks and shouldnt of made it pass Chris it should be Chris and Taylor in the Final but since it is not Taylor for the WIN because he has stayed true to himself and his fans and have add "Taylor" into each and every song he sang not just changing the song but singing it to the best of his ability and Kat has forgot the words to songs and she has not even tried to make them hers

Taylor

I say Taylor...we had four or five American idols star all singing the same type of music. Let the soul singer win!!!

I'm torn. I really like both of them. And I think Katherine would sell more records - she has the right voice and style to be a huge seller. But Taylor is more fun and he was better last night.

Based on last night's performance, I think Taylor should win. But I wouldn't be upset with either choice.

I want Taylor to win the American Idol..Go Soul Patrol! I also think that Kathrine would go somewhere with her talent regardless..Just as Chris would...I think the talented underdogs should get it.

I am all for Katherine!!

American Idol has something to do with the look too. Taylor looks like he is like 40 years old. She is beautiful, talented, and incredibly versatile. I am all for Katherine.

i agree with "waiting2inhale2" Katt was way off key on the end of her single, sad but true i was routin' for her till last night...Taylor did amazing but i can't say the same for McPhee...

Soul Patrol! Soul Patrol! Soul Patrol! Taylor. I tried to vote for him last night and couldn't get through. The person that voted 10 times thank you. I 'll count one of your votes for me.