Who thinks the guys in Supernova made a mistake?

Dilana fit the band the best. But maybe they did her a favor. She will do well on her own. I think this band will be a train wreck with Lucas. He moves like he has is smoking crack and having a seizure. He is creepy, and his voice is so limited to one type of song. Not the rocking style I think of when I see Gilby, Tommy and Jason. But with that said, I was surprised at how thier music sounded. Its very 80's. Magni sings great, but nothing about him on stage wows me. Toby would have been good for them.

I think Magni had it going on. But of Lucas and Dilana, I thought Dilana had far more talent. The trouble with Dilana though is that ALL songs will sound the same by her. That gravelly voice really can't hit range all that well. It's why 4 Non Blondes didn't last long.

From day one I could not look at him when he would sing and mostly started to fast fwd when he did :(

I really thought it would come down to Dilana and Toby, I wont be buying the Supernova CD when it comes out.

But for people who care :)

Dilana had an album in 2000 under Dilana Smith Wonderfool (itunes)

Ryan had one in 2005 with back of your car and some pretty good stuff (if you like him :) ) (itunes)

Lucas is creepy. I would have chosen Dilana or Toby. Probably Dilana. Dave Navarro wears more makeup than most women do. Maybe that's why they chose Lucas, so they can share eyeliner!

Dave Navrro IS a gay vampire, but aren't we all?

I agree, I think Rossi doesnt fit the band, although I didnt like him I think Toby would have been the best fit, the girl turnout would have quite possibly challenged that of Motley in its heyday.

Maybe thats why they didnt go with Toby, maybe uber-man-slut Tommy Lee is getting too old, Frankenewstead doesnt want a bunch of teenie boppers around to reject him YET again. And flipping Gilby is gayer than Navarro.

I like Dilana, but as much as i hate to play the Gender card, they just ARE NOT gonna have a chick front the band. Gilby is enough estrogen in that band.

And Magni, I liked, but he's pretty one dimensional and he started effing around and backtalking Tommy Lee.

big mistake, I thought I was maybe the only one, I dont like Lukas at all, he sings awful and I think Toby should be fronting that band, I think the band wont sell too many tickets, they were all expecting Toby or Dilana to win, did you see the audience too? They werent too happy. I love Tommy Lee!!

I don't see the attraction to Lucas at all ! ! !

Dilanna was a much better performer, and I love her voice.

I agree with the others. I won't be excited to hear any of Supernova's

stuff. It's like last year. The only person I didn't want to see picked was

the one that won last year! How many people think Dilanna's album is going to sell more than Supernova's ? ? ? ?

All four of the finalist were GREAT!!! However, I never expected Lucas to win. I really thought Toby was a no-brainer. Toby seemed to have the best interaction with the audience, he has a great voice, his original song was super, and he's hot too. Why do you think they cut Toby?

I agree...they made a big-time mistake. I don't think Lucas' voice is anything to write home about and his on-stage antics were mistaken for talent.

I also think live concerts are going to be a problem for him.... he was told that his singing method strains his voice and I can't see him doing 5 songs in a row in a concert setting.

Frankly, though, I don't really care..... The only musician from Supernova that I think is talented is Tommy Lee.

first if Dave is a vampire ( gay or otherwise) he can bite me ANYDAY!!!!!!!!!!!!

Lucas looks like a Tim Burton version of the singer Adam ant!!

I love Dilana...but I think she'll do better on her own. Because I have not been all that impressed with Supernova's music and I dont think they will last long.

Dilana has a classic unique voice...she can have an EXCELLENT solo career.

I thought they made a mistake last year too! I didnt like JD...but love Marty. and got to see him in concert about a month ago.....OMG does he MOVE like that off the stage too!!!!!!!!