If A.J Feely started instead of Jeff Garcia for the eagles, you think they would still have made the playoffs?

Garcia is a far better QB than Feely. They would be one of the first five in the draft if Feely was in there.

i agree, feely is a good short term back up, he can manage the game well for a week maybe two but you cannot expect him to be an every day starter and have that team make the playoffs, garcia as you said has shown the talent, toughness and the determination necessary to be the everyday starter.

and McNabb is definately not over rated, he just tried to do to much. If anything the media is to blame talking about how donovan was all the eagles had when they still had westbrook and lj smith and stallworth

Garcia brought a life to the Eagles McNabb Couldn't - Without that the Eagles would have done exactly what everybody expected - "McNabb is down - The Eagle's Season is Finished" They are better now than at any point in recent history - (Chargers will win it though!)

In my book Feely has already proved what he needed to last time McNabb got hurt,and then Koy Detmer got hurt playing San Fran.He steped up got the Eagles in the playoffs,only mistake was putting McNabb back in when he wasn't ready,If they put A.J. in I think he is very capable of doing the job.

Garcia is has more experience then Feely.

Garcia has turned this team around and is a true leader.

GO E A G L E S!!!

It's all specualtion, but Garcia's experience is coming through. He runs the Eagles offense much better than the overrated McNabb, and the rest of the Eagles are responding to him. Don't know if they would have with Feeley. And definitely not with McNabb.

nicely if the Jets did not suck donkey scrotum and received that recreation antagonistic to the Giants the Eagles would were in. I actually do not imagine they'd have received more beneficial than one recreation in spite of their end of season streak.

He did good last year for us maybe but Garcia is a three time pro bowler. GO EAGLES!!!!!!!!!!!1

no and finally I have something to back up my claims that McNabb is overrated...they'd be lucky to be 6-9 right now if McNabb were still starting

no way. garcia's opportunity and performance is this year is a once-in-a-lifetime occurance.