Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

How can I get the school to see that this isn't a problem?

My daughter is 7 and going into the second grade. She has friends and enjoys playing and interacting with friends. But at times she will prefer to sit alone to read, work and sometimes to eat. She's not teased and she is able to form close friendships, but the school keeps making a big deal out of the fact that at times she likes to be alone, even going so far as to say she needs intervention and counseling, so they send her to the school counselor once a week. I would see this a problem if it was all the time, but it's not, when she wants be alone she chooses to be alone and when she wants company she chooses to go hang out with other kids. She also has a very defined sense of personal space and only lets one or two very close friends hug her or sit/stand close to her. I don't see it as being a problem, but the school and her teachers keep acting like it is. Has anyone else had a situation where the school sees a problem but you don't, and how did you deal with it?

Update:

Even the principal pushes the counseling, and we did consent finally. I don't think the counseling is doing her any harm, my daughter sees it as getting to leave the classroom and go play with a nice lady and a couple of other kids, which basically is what it is, and the counselor doesn't seem to think my daughter has any real issues. I just wish that at every conference with a teacher I didn't have to hear how she's still not socializing enough, or not intiating interaction with other kids. In pre-school she woudln't talk to other kids at all and it was at the same school so I'm afraid that since she was labelled in pre-school, she'll have to carry that label with her. We are supposed to be moving soon, so maybe with a new school she can shake that label and the teachers won't be watching her so closely, waiting for her to "mess up" in their opinion.

12 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Have you talked to the principal? Sometimes that helps. She's your kid, not theirs so they shouldn't be able to make her go to counseling without your permission. I would also explain to them that they aren't really promoting individuality, but instead making it seem like there's something psychologically wrong with her because she's not acting or doing all of the things that the other kids do. In the end, they could potentially end up making her feel like there's something wrong with her (in a bad way) and then really mess her up psychologically.

  • 1 decade ago

    You need to express to them exactly how you feel. Maybe with a sit down with the principle,teachers,and the counselor. That way the counselor can even back up your claim that their is nothing wrong with wanting to be alone at times as long as it isn't all the time. Remind them that she has grown very much so since she was in pre-school. She has just learned early on what a lot of people take forever to realise, that everyone doesn't deserve to be in your close company. Tell them that as the parent you are okay with your child's behavior and don't wish for them to take it upon theirselves in changing YOUR child. That is the last of the conversation you want you or your child to hear of it. Also, by them pushing her to do this they are furthur labeling her and alienating her..she doesn't need others trying to change something thats not a problem at such a crucial age in her developement.

  • 1 decade ago

    Are you moving within the same school district though? In our district, when kids switch schools, they fax the child's record to the new school, so the counseling would be listed on there, as well as the reasons why she is going to these sessions. However, if you are moving out of district, you will be given the records, or should be at least, and so you can choose to not give them that paperwork.

    And my daughter will spend time doing her own thing at school and at home as well. She isn't worried about personal space, she loves to give and get hugs from friends (except one who is really exuberant and tends to accidentally hurt the friends she hugs). But I think it shows that kids are way more aware of themselves and others to know what they want to do and when. It is something to be encouraged, not quashed.

    Good luck!

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I'm much like you're daughter, except older. I love being around my friends, but I'm not a lovey-touchy kind of person and apparently, neither is your daughter. There's nothing wrong with her wanting to be alone sometimes. I'd seriously suggest getting a large staff meeting with her teacher, cousenlor, principal, and other staff involved to show them that there is nothing wrong with your daughter wanting a little space sometimes. Don't let all the adults do all the talking, though. Ask your daughter why she wants to be alone and if she'd rather be alone sometimes. She knows that she wants some personal space. Her school doesn't seem like a very good one, in my opinion.

    Just because other kid's parents don't give them enough attention and they crave every speck they can get, doesn't mean your daughter is in the same positon. If they can't see things your and your daughter's way, send her to another school. It's not worth it for her to have to stay at a place where she's constantly pestered to be with a friend.

    There's nothing wrong with her not wanting to hug or sit/stand close to someone. I won't even let my mother kiss me, not even on the cheek. I pretty much try to avoid good-bye hugs and no one is allowed to stand closer than four inches from me. Some people I'll let hug me once in a while, but otherwise, I just wonder why people can't just keep to themselves.

    I'm very independent myself and would rather sit alone in my room doing nothing than forced to play outside with a bunch of kids I don't know. No there is nothing wrong with me. I'm not depressed or something similiar. I like being around people I'm comfortable with. It takes me a while to warm up to people. I can't relate to many kids my age, actually. A lot of them are gross and are quite rude and mean sometimes. Kids my age and older tend to intimidate me. I will usually only hang out with my friends, who are usually in my grade, or one below or one under.

    Well, now that my latest biography is over, I've come to the conclusion that you're daughter just might be a bit like me in that she's more independent then some adults think normal. At her age, you'll usually find kids wanting to be around other kids every chance they get. Some just like quiet time to themselves where they can think there own thoughts and imagine instead of being interrupted constantly. Nothing wrong with that.

  • 1 decade ago

    Barring acts of violence, she shouldn't be forced to do anything without your consent. Even the counseling is by your consent. Talk to the teachers, counselors and principals. If needed, go to the school board with your concerns.

    Request documentation to show how they seem to think she needs counseling.

    It could be that the school is trying to fulfill a quota.

    Good luck.

  • 1 decade ago

    Talk to the counsellor. By the sounds of it your daughter is a very healthy girl (socially, emotionally etc) Maybe if the counsellor went into the classroom to observe her, she might see that she interacts with others as well as has "alone time". I drive a $70,000 car (2-seater) to get my alone time I'm sure even the principal goes into their office and shuts the door for some "alone time".

  • 1 decade ago

    I think you need to request a meeting between you, the principal, the teachers, and the counselor. It doesn't sound like they are communicating among themselves. It might be beneficial if the counselor explains what she sees so that the others can understand that it is okay to be alone at times.

  • Pooka
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    Ugh. Welcome to the wonderful world of teaching conformity at a young age.

    Steve Miller has a cute story in which his child liked to color outside of the lines in coloring books in class.

    The teacher sent a note;

    "Your child likes marches to his own beat,but we'll have him following the drummer soon enough!" With a cute little picture.

    The only thing you can do is instruct the school to leave your child alone.

    But you'll probably have to switch her to a different school or she'll never get any peace from the staff. This sort of treatment can create problems where there aren't any.

  • Rachel
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    sometimes the schools see things that us mums can't as we are too close to see it. Councelling is not a bad thing and should not be looked on this way. I know it can be hard to think that something is wrong but when a school see's hundreds of kids go through the school they know when something just isn't quite right. Accept the help even if there is no real problem it is not going to hurt her

  • 1 decade ago

    i was not a social child. schools tried the same with me. if the counselors arent hurting her and if theres no cost then just let it go. Schools have issues with children that dont fit within their little box forms, and if they dont they think they need to be adjusted so that they do. if the counselor is doing harm, demand that the school stop those sessions immediately

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.