Doctor Who fans is it a good idea to bring Rose back next year?

I hope she doesn't come back. The revolving door of companions is part of the show. On top of all that, Rose left a bad taste in my mouth. She was really mean to Mickey and her family. She almost destroyed time once to see her dad and then in the alternate cybermen universe, she didn't listen to the Doctor AGAIN, after she said she would. They also shouldn't have brought back Tate(the bride).

I think they should in the same fashion they brought back Sgt Benton, Brigadier Leithbridge Steward, Sarah-Jane Smith, the Monk, K-9, Mickey, Pete Tyler and the occasional baddies.

If it is well handled, not in a StarStrek Voyager Paramount fashion, they could also bring back Suzan or her descendance as well (Hoping there's half Gallifreyan left because of her!) for just maybe a brief moment that HELP the script or the drama. Even if not an actual physical presence! She's in Torchwood on the otherside, why not trying to work with that for an accidental communication breach between dimensions? Well, I admit I'd like to see back Leela, Romana and Ace! ;)

The Doctor has had so many companions over the years that I think he should just move on. Frankly, I think it's the new fans who need to move on. Rose wasn't his first companion, or his first love. It's part of the character and part of the show. Her fans need to let go of Rose and enjoy whoever comes along for the ride instead of obsessing.

she should come back. The docotr has never "loved" a companion like the way he loves rose. not to mention billie piper and david tennant have great chemistry on screen not only this but her character made the show seem more human since it was being told from her point of view. Then there is the fact that i do not like catharine tate, and i think i will like freeyma more on torchwood.

I've been a Dr Who fan since the series originally started. This chemistry between Dr Who and Rose is something that really is unique and original (To Dr Who) and gives additional depth to the stories.

And without stating the obvious, isn't the Doctor the last of his race?

I liked rose and would like to see her back....

No, it isn't a good idea at all . . . . . . . . IT'S AN EXCELLENT IDEA! I can't WAIT to see her back!