Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Regular Tetrahedron and 4 Parallel Planes?
Do You remember the old problem about the equilateral triangle on the rails? Given are 3 co-planar parallel lines, the distance between 1st and 2nd is a, between 2nd and 3rd - b (and a + b between 1st and 3rd of course).
Please follow the link below to see a picture:
http://i219.photobucket.com/albums/cc101/Andrey_Dy...
Easily follows that for all a ≥ 0 and b ≥ 0 there exists an equilateral triangle, having one vertex on each line with side length:
(2/√3)*√(a² + ab + b²)
Now the 3D analog: imagine 4 parallel planes at distances a, b and c between them. Does a regular tetrahedron exist, having one vertex on each plane? If so, find its edge length.
1 Answer
- Zo MaarLv 51 decade agoFavorite Answer
EDIT:
I noticed that I use different notation.
In my notation, a, b, and c are distances
between the lowest plane and the other planes -
not the distances between neighboring planes.
To make transition to the original notation
one should make the substitutions: a=a, b = a+b, c = a+b+c
(left sides are my a, b and c).
Then the answer will be
X = √ (3*a^2/2+2*b^2+3*c^2/2+2ab+ac+2bc).
One more remark. Once we know that the required construction exists, it is easy to calculate the polyhedron edge X. X^2 is a quadratic function of distances a, b, c (in my notation). The expression should be symmetric to arbitrary permutatons of [a, b, c]. Then X^2 = s1 (a^2+b^2+c^2) + s2 (ab+ac+bc), where s1 and s2 are some constants. In two limits a=0, b=0, and a=b=c, c is equal to the height of a regular polyhedron: c/X=√ (2/3). Applying the above expression to these two limits we have s1=3/2, 3(s1+s2) = 3/2, and hence s2 = -1.
*****************************************************
Choose the coordinate system, such as the lowest plane passes through the cooridnate origin (0,0,0). Put the vertex v_0 of the tetrahedron in the coordinate origin. The other 3 vertices have coordinates:
Eq. (1)
v_1=(0, L, L),
v_2=(L, 0, L),
v_3=(L, L, 0).
Here, L is some number. The distance between any two vertices v_i and v_j is equal to L √ 2, so this is a regular tetrahedron.
Let P=(P_x,P_y,P_z) is the unit vector normal to the planes. The vertices of the tetrahedron lie on planes, if and only if v_j have the form v_j = d_j P + Q_j, where d_j =a, b, c, and Q_j are some vectors perpendicular to P. Taking scalar products of these relations with the vector P, we have v_j*P_j = d_j, or
y + z = a,
x + z = b,
x + y = c,
where x= L*P_x, y=L*P_y, z=L*P_z. The solution is
Eq. (2)
x = (-a+b+c)/2,
y = (a-b+c)/2,
z = (a+b-c)/2.
This means that by choosing L = √(x^2+y^2+z^2); and P = (x,y,z)/L we solve the problem.
The edge length X of the tetrahedron is equal to
X = L √ 2=
√ (3a^2/2+3b^2/2+3c^2/2-ab-ac-bc).
For explicit construction we start with an arbitrary coordinate system. For given a, b, and c we calculate x,y,z, according to Eq. (2) and build the tetrahedron according to Eq. (1). Then draw the vector P and build the planes. After that, we can rotate and shift this construction to transform the planes into the desired position.