Do You Agree With These QB's?

Where is Trent Dilfer and Vinny Testeverde?

No. First drop Young from the list.. he's not that good QB.. compare to the rest..

Derek Anderson and Romo should not be considered as top QB cause they are not time-tested...

Carson Palmer, Drew Brees, and Ben Roethlisberger are very good but somewhat inconsistent..

Peyton Manning and Tom Brady they are the best QB in the league.. and they are definitely the hall of famers

Brett Favre.. He's a living legend, and a hall of famer.

1. Brady

2. Manning (Peyton, not Eli)

3. Romo

4. Favre

5. Garrard (VERY Underrated player)

6 Brees

7. Roethlisberger

8. Palmer

9. Anderson

10. Kitna

And for the person who wonders what Brady would do without all his great receivers? How about win 3 Super Bowls with only Troy Brown as a pro-bowler (marginal at that) in 2001?

1.Tom Brady

2.Peyton Manning

3.Brett Favre

4.Matt Hasselbeck

5.Tony Romo

6. Drew Brees

7.Marc Bulger

8.Carson Palmer

9.Ben Roethlisberger

10.Jon Kitna

Does nobody know who Hasselbeck and Bulger are?? they have to be in the top 10!

take vince young off of the list please, you think the titans win because of him? no no no its the titan defense that actually keeps them in the game and vince will probably do one last drive for a GW field goal, thats it, nothing else.

brady and manning can be debated over 1&2 and favre and romo can be debated over 3&4 but all 4 are excellent QBs. Mcnabb is not the same anymore, and i wouldnt consider him a top 10 QB. take off mcnabb and vince young and put on jay cutler and matt hasselbeck than theres the top 10

You got it all wrong.

1.Brady, will easily beat Faves records with time.

2.Farve He is a god.

3Romo the next Brady/Farve in my book

4.Manning no way number 1 overratted with out wayne and Harrison hes a nobody but i will give the nubers advatage over the rest below him.

5.A.J. Feleey did you see the game against the pats?

6.David Garrard look at his int. sorry lack there of.

7.Big ben drops a little thaks to injury and his season.

8.Jon Kitna look what he;s done for the LIONS!

9.Derek Anderson he;s done wonders for the browns

10.Palmer not a good year but he is still a good QB

I would...

change # 1 to # 3

change # 3 to # 2

change # 2 to # 1

Though idk if I would rank Brees that high. He isn't playing like a top 5 QB but more like a 7 or 8. Also, im not sure about Big Ben being # 7, but he isn't playing like a top 5 QB to me either right now. Have to see how this weeks goes. Where is Hasseslback? bring him in, drop Young to 11 move everyone else down 1, bring Big Ben up one to about 6* maybe 5 but that is a huge maybe*

but that is just my opinion.

Careerwise, absolutely not!!!

If Brady didn't have all the weapons around him, he wouldn't be as good as a qb. Take mediocre players and see how well Brady does. He would flop.

1. Favre

2. Brady

3. Manning

4. Romo

The rest look okay

1. Favre

2. Brady

3. Peyton

4. Romo

5. Roethlisberger

6. Palmer

7. Brees

8. McNabb

9. Anderson

10. Young

How the hell could you put Favre 3rd? Peyton is hardly the best. Brady has more rings, than Peyton, and a better record against him. Roethlisberger has a ring, but I feel Romo has more potential, and will get at least 1 ring before he's done.

McNabb and Young are NOT in the top 10