How would you rank these hitters?

Wow you certainly have quite a list of tremendous players and all gifted in different ways. This is how I would draft them:

Roberto Clemente had all the tools of a complete player. He could run, throw, and hit for average and with power. Best arm I've ever seen and a complete hitter.

Hitting: 8 out of 10

Defense: 10 out of 10

Power: 6 out of 10

Speed: 7 out of 10

Leadership: 9 out of 10

Total: 40 points

Carl Yaztrezemski had a determination and focus you rarely see in a ballplayer with great baseball instincts and a fearless player who was a great fielder and hitter.

Hitting: 7 out of 10

Defense: 8 out of 10

Speed: 5 out of 10

Power: 7 out of 10

Leadership: 9 out of 10

Total; 36 points

Pete Rose always played the game the way it was meant to be played, hard and at all times. He played the game as if his life depended on it.

Hitting; 7 out of 10

Defense: 7 out of 10

Speed: 6 out of 10

Power: 4 out of 10

Leadership: 8 out of 10

Total 32 points

Robin Yount had the skill to play at many different positions and hit for a decent average with good power. Very determined and hardnosed player.

Hitting: 6 out of 10

Defense: 7 out of 10

Speed: 7 out of 10

Power: 5 out of 10

Leadeship: 7 out of 10

Total: 32 points

1. Roberto Clemente

2. Pete Rose

3. Carl Yastrzemski

4. Robin YOunt

1. Pete Rose

2. Roberto Clemente

3. Carl Yastzemski

4. Robin Yount

Roberto Clemente

Carl Yastrzemski

Pete Rose

robin yount

Clemente was quite the baller.....could hit anything and would run like a deer to stretch a single into a double.

Pete Rose was Charlie Hustle, enough said.

Yazoo was a pull hitter to right field that "fit" well at Fenway.

But Robin Yount was under-rated his entire career because I'm thinking he played in middle market.

That said, I'd rank them:

Rose

Clemente

Yount

Yazz

...even though Yazz was one of my favorites as a kid....

Pete Rose # 1

Pobin Yount # 2

Carl Yastrzemski # 3

Roberto Clemente # 4

All these players are really good.

Well, I would actually leave them the way they are place at the top: (1)Roberto Clemente, (2)Pete Rose, (3)Carl Yastrzemski, & (4)Robin Yount.

I wouldn't consider either of these a home run threat, they all had their unique ability & some more than others. Pete Rose I believe had the most power out of all of them. But if you count speed, I would say tha Roberto Clemente would lead in this category. There is one thing that all of these players have in common & that's the way the played the game. They all gave it their best & played with heart, not mattering the mney they earn or the way they look. These players were ballplayers of old.

1 pete rose 2 robin yount 3 roberto clemente 4 carl yascermaski

1) Roberto Clemente - The best all-around ball player on this list. He had the right amount of power and contact to get on base, then cause problems on the base paths. I wish we could have seen him finish the career he started.

2) Pete Rose - He didn't earn the nickname "Charlie Hustle" for nothing. I don't care about his rap about betting on sports. (in my own opinion, that is not enough to keep the game's all-time hit king out of the HOF...we need to get his butt into Cooperstown as a player!)

3) Robin Yount - Another remarkable hitter. It was always fun to watch him play the game. A scrappy guy who knew how to play the game.

4) Carl Yastremski - As all of these other great players, he was as good as they come, but it is hard to stand up to these other amazing players.

roberto Clemente-1

Pete Rose-2

Robin Yount-3

carl- never heard of...