Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Divorced with moving restrictions....?

I have a 75 mile radius limitation in my divorce agreement....My children are 10 and 13. Living in NY, the magic number for kids is 14 (no judge will force visitation on a kid 14 and older). My ex does NOT take full advantage of his visitation rights...nor is he current in his support obligations....My doctor has reccommended a change of location for me....New York is too stressful, and financially we would be better off in another state. I have never withheld visitation...this is not about escaping the sperm donor. However, it took 5 1/2 years to divorce him because he couldn't earn his right to UNsupervised visitation. (The courts and a psychologist as well as social workers monitored his visitation.) He is not approachable to seek an agreement outside of court. So, my question is.....can I based on medical/financial needs seek to move out of state and win in a NY court?

Update:

I expect to hear other people's experiences.....I have an attorney but at $500 per hour, I thought I'd try people's experiences first.

Update 2:

I absolutely know my divorce degree...it's a $50,000 document that I've committed to memory....yep, I can leave NYS but in order to be financially stable I need to move to Pennsylvania....the tristate area is killing me. NJ and CT are just as expensive as NY.

Update 3:

Although your math sounds appealing, my divorce says I must be within a 75 mile radius of my current home.

6 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I'm an attorney, but not in NY. I have handled cases where the custodial parent wishes to move, however. Both the fact that he has not exercised his visitation rights and that he is not current in his child support weigh in your favor. although child support and visitation are two separate issues. If you can show a judge the move would beneift your children, you chances are good because of his lack of visitation. Financial benefits to the children through increased income is significant because he is behind in his support. Where you want to move to would be an important issue. The age of the children work to your advantage. Very young children need to see both parents more frequently because their memories are not fully developed. You have nothing to lose by filing this Motion to Modify except the attorney fees. You don't even know if he will mount an effective defense. Despite the expense, you should consult an attorney. Who is the judge? What is the judge's "track-record" on this types of Motions? You need a local attorney to really assess your chances of success. You would have an excellent chance in my state, but NY divorce laws are strange. NY is one of the only states that does not recognize "no-fault" divorces.

  • 1 decade ago

    You need to talk to an attorney and social services.

    Seriously, do you expect a good answer from strangers who spend their time hanging out on the internet?

    I would have probably gotten custody of my children if the Jedi had not hidden them from me.

  • ?
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    I would talk to an attorney and have them file paperwork and get the court's approval now..that way nothing is holding you back when the time comes. Since your ex does not live in California anymore then they probably will grant your request. I think the only reason why you couldn't move out of San Diego County was because he had visitation 3 out of 4 weekends and was living there but since that is not the case anymore then you shouldn't have a problem. Good Luck!

  • 1 decade ago

    You have a 75 mile radius. Lets do a little math.

    A = Pi* R^2. 3.14 x 75 x 75 = 17,622.5 square miles.

    That is a pretty big territory to be able to move around in. That is almost 40% of the area of New York state. How exactly can you not find a job within that area?

    Read your divorce decree CAREFULLY. All you have to do is comply with what it specifically says. And it may not say you have to stay in New York State.

    Lets assume you are close to a border with another state. If the limit is 75 miles, with no comment about you having to stay in New York state, you can move into the neighboring state and still comply with the 75 mile order.

    You could even move into Canada if you are close enough.

    Remember, comply with the divorce decree. I doubt it says you have to stay in NY State.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Ron N
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    You have apparently gone through this proceducre with some

    kind of legal advice,, would certainly follow that approach again. This is purely dependent on the family court judge you

    are in front of. Take your medical evidence, your financial documentation,, and with No And I do Mean NO emotion, go into a hearing with straight up dollors and sense facts. With

    the intent leaning for the betterment of your children and yourself... I see No reason why you shouldn't be able to get

    a sympathetic ear,

    Good luck.

  • 1 decade ago

    You will have a tough fight ahead of you. Many women have tried moving away from dad because of stress or financial reasons and have not been successful because it would seriously impair the visitation or custody rights of the father. If you can offer to the court that you are willing to pay for your ex to visit the kids then they might be more willing, which in your current financial circumstances seems a little ridiculous. I would give your current situation another year or two...keep documentation about how much dad isn't around and you might have a better chance. If your doc thinks you are stressed out...maybe you need to get into counseling...which can also be used for reasons to move...keep records of everything...a doctor's recommendation is NOT enough...get records of medication if you take it...counseling if you are going and time that your ex skips seeing his children...if you have a LONG history of this (and I mean at least a year of this) then you might have something to take back to court. Also, being behind in child support will have NO effect on whether you can move out of NY...so you can bring it up but it is not going to sway the judge's decision. Visitation and support are two separate issues. Good luck.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.