is Eli Manning the BEST QB EVER??'?

you need to stay off the juice or the crack or both of them just because eli is going to super bowl for the first time makes him the best ever he has to prove him self over period of time and longevity wise he is just starting out so i wouldnt even put him at top 200 all time

please stay off the drugs it has distorted your rational thinking and look at reality GO PACKS GO NEXT YEAR

Oh, please guy! purely throwing passes up for grabs? You mean like Brady does for Moss? supply Eli the credit he merits. He truthfully would have taken the sack, yet he have been given away, accumulated himself, took his time and threw a grasp bypass. If Eli became so fortunate, then how do you clarify the bypass that went off Steve Smith's palms and became intercepted? That wasn't his fault. Eli could get the credit, he's the guy! He beat Captain u.s. Brady, and helped flush the Patriots' acceptable checklist down the rest room! and you nonetheless could not admit which you have been incorrect once you pronounced that the sport may be the backside-rated super Bowl in years. i assume you're actually not a "massive boy", are you?

No, he is not the best ever. And probbly never will be. His whole career will be tarnished by the, "I'm not going to San Diego" thing. Even if he wins 10 super bowls, he is childish. No one likes a whiner.

He has grown up, I will give him that. He should have just kept his mouth shut and talked to the mangers in SD before he did all that. He screwed his team(NYG) b doing that also. Nate Keading, Merriman, and some other guy or Eli. Come on now....

Tom Brady isn't the best QB for all of those that say he is. one good season means NOTHING. Most of the years before this he didn't even hit 4000yards, if marvin is alive Peyton will break it again.

Eli will be better than his brother, due to his ability to play in the playoffs and on the road. In 2years Eli will be the best QB in the league.

Best Ever? He just won his 1st play off game!! Won 3 playoff games and now building resume.After ELI & Giants win Super Bowl he can be mentioned as winning Quarterback however has long way to go before being considered greatest of all time!!!

Make me laugh

These names sound familiar? Joe Montana? Dan Marino? John Elway? Troy Aikman? Terry Bradshaw? Hell, even Peyton Manning? And the only one greater than all of those mentioned, Tom Brady? You know what all these quarterbacks have in common?

They'd pwn Eli Manning any day, sorry to break it to you.

No, his brother is the best. Eli is not even in the top 100.

Yes eli rules...he is by far the best ever

followed by philip rivers

Cops smoking crack???

What's next?

Eli rocks, he's a nice guy, but get real.

He would barely be on the long list.

yeah right who cares about Montana and Manning and Favre

lets just say Eli is better than them