Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

David M asked in SportsBaseball · 1 decade ago

Give me your best lineup of players who had their careers cut short by something unrelated to baseball.?

Accidents and illness have cut short a lot of players careers. Give me a lineup by position of the best of these trajic figures.

9 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Roberto Clemente#21: The first latino inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame and was a pioneer for the hispanic community. He tragically died in a plane crash delivering relief to Nicaragua after thay had suffered a massive earthquake. Career .317 hitter and finished with exactly 3000 hits.

  • JIK
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    Many of the people I would have said are already listed (Gehrig, Munson, Clemente, Bostock, Campanella, etc.)

    A couple others:

    Ugueth Urbina -- currently in a Venezuelan prison

    Cory Lidle -- plane crash

    And how about managers Dick Howser (cancer) and Gil Hodges (heart attack).

    Note to Medadme... That was Ray Fosse, not Ray Hasse. Otherwise you had an interesting list.

    And to the person who said Gehrig's career was already ending. No way.

  • 1 decade ago

    C - Therman Munson

    1B - Don Mattingly

    2B -

    3B -

    SS - Ron Hansen

    LF - Lyman Bostock

    CF - Kirby Puckett

    RF - Roberto Clemente

    DH - Ed Delahanty

    P - Sandy Koufax

    Couldn't really come up with a 2B or 3B, but here's my all-time cut-short team. I won't mention Gehrig because he had a long career, and was really at the end of it when ALS began to take him away.

    Everyone on this list either died or had a natural injury that robbed them of their talent. Puckett's glaucoma along with Hansen and Mattingly's back had nothing to do with baseball, nor did Bostock's gunshot, or Munson and Clemente's tragic airplane crashes, or Koufax' arthritis.

  • 1 decade ago

    I'm gonna try and come up with some people that aren't the norm. But good/great players none-the-less.

    Chief Sockalexis - O- good enought to have the Cleveland Indians named after him.

    Ross Youngs -O- Died from Brights Disease. Hall of Famer.

    Steve Howe -P- Drugs

    J.R. Richard -P- blood clot

    Jackie Jensen -1b- fear of flying

    Nick Estasky(spelling?) -1b- Vertigo

    Chuck Knoblauch -2b- mental blockage where he could not throw where aimed.

    Ray Hasse -C- Injured while getting bowled over at the plate by Pete Rose. Yes, it did happen during a baseball game. But it was the All-Star game.

    Steve Blass -P- mental blockage. He simply could not throw strikes.

    Kevin Seitzer - 3b- Cancer. Did come back, but was never what he once was.

    Then there is Ted Williams, among 100's of others, who lost 6 years to the war. Most of those were in the prime of his career.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • C- Roy Campanella( CAr Crash)

    1B- Lou Gehrig (Illness)

    SS- Mike Sharperson (car crash)

    Of- Roberto Clemente (plane Crash)

    OF- Kirby Puckett (glaucoma)

    OF- Bo Jackson( football injury)

    P- Addie Joss (meningitis)

    RP- Donnie Moore( suicide)

  • 1 decade ago

    Kenny Hubbs -- Rookie of the year Cub who died in a helicopter crash.

    Kirby Puckett -- glaucoma.

    Lou Gehrig

    Lymon Bostock -- shot (mistaken identity)

    Thurmon Munson -- airplane accident

    Jimmy Piersall -- mental problems

    Ed Delahantey -- Mysterious death

  • 1 decade ago

    C-Roy Campanella/ Thurman Munson(Campy was much better but I'm a Munson fan).

    1B-Lou Gherig

    2b-Ken Hubbs ---22yo died plane crash

    3b- none I can think of

    ss- Roy Chapman----29 yo died from beanball skull fracture

    of- Roberto Clemente

    of- Kirby Puckett

    of- Lyman Bostock---27yo shot in backseat of a car

    P- Addie Joss---31 Tubercular meningitis

    Source(s): an amazing memory for the darker things
  • 1 decade ago

    Lou Gehrig - 1B

    always comes to mind first

    Thurmon Munson - C

    Lyman Bostock - OF

  • 1 decade ago

    The lists above me are great but people are forgetting that Dave Dravecky was finally putting together a nice career when Cancer took his ability to pitch away from him.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.