Project Runway 4: Which of the 3 designers would you have chosen?

Rami. Definitely. I could actually imagine wearing much of his stuff. Christian's looked great on tall skinny models, but who else could wear is work? Jillian is talented, too, but I felt her collection was kind of a mess. She tried to do too much and, in my opinion, it looked cheap.

I really liked Rami's style. He has the nature of the female figure down to a T...well, at least the skinny model figure. Jillian did well and I really did like her knits, but it was very simplified and there was very little cohesion in her collection...nothing really matched as much as it should have. And I would have loved to see more of her coats and the detail work she put into them. Christian was just over the top, and I'll have to agree with the comment about Posh being the guest judge...her tastes put Rami and Jillian totally out of the picture. Chris's collection probably would have given Christian a run for it's money, but the world may never know. The show has gone on long enough for it's viewers to know that it is all about shocking people and making them go "oooohhh, that's different". After all, Santino did a wonderful collection and still lost. And I can't agree with Jeffery winning last year - Michael's collection was much more wearer-friendly.

I liked both Rami's and Jillian's better than Christian's line. I thought Christian's all looked the same. If I had to choose I'd pick Rami, but Jillian runs a very close second. I don't know why he won, I was disappointed with the judges choice.

I would have voted for Jillian.

The judges had stated that Jillian had come up with designs they had never seen before and that her clothing was something they feel is more aesthetically appealing to women.

And then Rami did an incredible job with the weaving patterns.

The judges said that Christians clothing was not made for everyone, and Tim Gunn even stated that Christians' clothing is more in tune with costume design than high fashion design.

I think the only reason Christian won was because of that lame wad British beyotch stating she would wear his clothes.

I too am disappointed with the final decision.

Christian

Jillian and

Chris

Christian was the right pick for winner...he has been consistently throughout the season and he makes the most beautiful clothes. Not to mention he is a hoot!!! His collection was the most well put together, yes he could have taken some chances with color. But otherwise they picked the right person.

I really liked Jillian's outfits, they seem like something the every-day woman could wear. I didn't like Rami's color choice. Christians, to me, was over-the-top.

I wish Jillian would have won.

I thought Rami would win til Christian came out with his collection AND Posh was a guest judge. Cant stand her! But it was her style of clothing. The rest were doomed

Rami should have won, Really who wears that crap the Christian designs. I was quite disgusted.

Christian hands down! Noone could compete with this FIERCE collection!