Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Why is it that the tribe of Judah won't acknowledge the existence of the other tribes?
There were 12 Tribes - Paul was a Benjamite, a descendant of Benjamin, that does not make him a Jew, but he was an Israelite.
Thank you - I'm from the tribe of Ephraim too.
8 Answers
- Anonymous1 decade agoFavorite Answer
Mr Maurog is right.
during the reign of Solomon’s son, King Rehoboam, the kingdom of Israel split. 10 tribes followed Jeroboam in rebellion making the northern kingdom = Israel. Only Judah, and Benjamin and the Levites (who were scattered in the towns and cities) remained loyal to Rehoboam. These 3 tribes make up the southern kingdom = Judah.
read 1 Kings 12
Paul was a citizen of the kingdom of Judah(ie a Jew). But he wasn't just a Jew. nor was he merely a Benjamite. He was both. by birth, of the tribe of Benjamin - by national citizenship, a Jew. Philippians 3.5
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Uh, Judah is a merge of three tribes, one of them Benjamin.
They were living too close and people intermarried until it was impossible to distinguish which is which. So they now are called by the largest of the original tribes, Judah. Judah, Simeon and Benjamin merged into Judah, but Levi which also was mingled in them did not, because Levites were a cleric caste, marrying only within themselves.
Also, all 12 tribes are Jews, so the point is moot.
- 1 decade ago
Er, yes, that would make him a Jew.
Although the general name for the Jews originally comes from Judah's name, it includes all 12 of the tribes, not just Judah.
- MLv 71 decade ago
Thanks "jofuss" for sources!!!
Problem here is a Christian invention.
Judaism and its liturgies do not recognize NT, its teachings, its Apostles including "Paul"
And since the NT liturgies are not recognized by Judaism, the liturgies utilized by Judaism have no relevance to Christianity.
Therefore when claim is made of "tribe" based on OT "Kings 12" as compared to NT "Philippians 3.5" this is non-sequitor, "it does not compute".
Mitigating reasons for this include:
Both the Question and the Answers above are very narrow and very "Christian" of both OT and NT.
Understanding of the OT by Christendom is usually vastly different than the same OT understood by Judaism.
Judaism understands its liturgies.
Christendom almost universally misunderstands (by Judaism's standards) Judaism's liturgies.
Christendom utilizes to near exclusion only "English" and does not recognize the supporting liturgies such as Talmud, Torah shebik'Tav - Oral Torah, Mishnah, Midrashim, Zoharic writings, etc.
Judaism's understandings of OT is a very stark contrast to the Christian understandings of OT due in very large part to Judaism's usage of both the original Hebrew and the supporting liturgies.
Judaism's understanding does not recognize NT liturgies such as that known as "Philippians 3.5".
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
because of the scattering that took place in the old testament
of the tribes...judah has been kept more intact than the others.
- primoa1970Lv 71 decade ago
Paul was a Jew...............and it really doesn't matter what he was. All I know is that the Lord used him in a mighty way
- Anonymous1 decade ago
YEA WE DO AND THE 12 TRIBES ARE STILL IN EXISTANCE TODAY
LOOK IT UP THE 12 TRIBES OF ISRAEL ARE THE SO ALLED N3GROS..HISPANICS..AND WEST IDIANS