Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Steve asked in HealthMental Health · 1 decade ago

Self Harming......A form of DEPRESSION?

I know someone who has started harming themselves (Deep scratching) and feels very low what should I do?

On discovering the scratching I was told to leave, but couldn't do that which then for a time made things worse, but I think I managed to talk things around. I am still here today, and things sem more calm, I am wondering if it was the alcohol that made things worse, it wasn't a large amount from what I saw evidence of but worrying all the same. Any advice please?

17 Answers

Relevance
  • Emmy
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Alcohol will not make it better.

    The person needs to face up to whatever is bothering them, and come to deal with that pain. Self-injuring people are hurting themselves so that they can feel pain, and have it feel "real", because they can't come to terms with what is really bothering them, whether it be depression, or something more specific. The person definetely needs someone to talk to. If that is too hard, suggest a journal, and maybe at some point that person will be ready to share the journal with you, since speaking it out loud maybe too painful.

    Good luck to your friend. All things pass in time, you just have to be strong enough to make it through it.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Yes you're right, alcohol can really exacerbate the situation. I went through a time of drinking ost nights even though it wasn't much and i found myself increasing my self harm behaviours and ending up in hospital. Since then i drink less often and it has had a massive effect. I also started using relaxation techniques which has helped and with the help of my psychologist i have put into place distracting and coping mechanism. Try and find out when you are most calm and what it is that makes you calm and build on it. All the best x

  • 1 decade ago

    ABSOLUTELY DEPRESSION, including the alcohol used to "self-medicate"- take away the bad thoughts, which does not work.

    #1- this is a "clinical" (real and serious disease that is ruining the person's life and could be fatal by suicide or drunken accident) dis-order of the mood center of the brain, very common, treated by a psychiatrist with medication.

    #2- it can be very hard, sometimes impossible, to get the person into treatment. One symptom is a lot of fear they don't want to face, thus alcohol, and another is the conviction they are not sick, only a bad person in hiding. This is called "denial"

    #3- if you get them to a doctor they may argue with the doctor, who knows all about it because it is part of the sickness, and refuse to cooperate or return.

    #4- the medicines can be a very difficult story- there are so many of them and they all work differently in different people.

    They also commonly have unpleasant side effects, some temporary and some not. It's a process of juggling and trial-and-error a sick person who doesn't think they need it often refuses to follow.

    #5- It is very common that when the medicines work, the patient feels fine, and quickly concludes they weren't sick after all, or now they're cured, and refuse to take them, which gets you right back where you started from.

    The bottom line is that the person must reach a point where they simply cannot go on the way they are. Then they die (no kidding), hide (in their room or into homelessness, or jail, or mental institution) or do what they need to do to live, relapses and all.

    I know- I've been there- my life is that of a person with clinical depression- l cope and compensate every day, no fun at all -worth it? depends on the day or even the minute you ask.

    What can you do? depends on the relationship- but the choices are: leave them alone, either because it's not worth it to you or to save your own life...appeal to their pride or to their responsibility to God, to spouse or children... or have them committed. Fear of consequences won't do any good because their actions are dictated by their emotions, which they cannot control and are out of whack.

    Sorry to be so bleak, but that's the story. A former Surgeon-General of the US, Dr Koop, estimated that 20% of Americans, one out of five, suffer from clinical depression (not the blues, which go away) and most of them are not diagnosed, not treated, don't know they have an illness.

  • 1 decade ago

    I don't know too much on this subject but have worked in a custodial job for a long time and have come across this type of thing a lot. As i didn't understand it, as the thought of cutting myself turns my stomach, i asked the psychologists i worked with and apparently what happens is the person has a build up of pressure that they feel they are reaching boiling point and once the blood flows they release the hormones that have caused the build up of pressure in the blood. Instantly feeling better. In a similar way to when a woman suffers from pre menstrual tension, as soon as the blood comes there is instant relief. As for what you think you should do, well it depends on the severity i suppose, if it is just scratching so no blood is drawn then i would be tempted to put it down to attention seeking, however if they are drawing bllod and the cuts are deep then i think the time has come to try and get specialist help as to why your friend is having these feelings.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    Alcohol is baaad because it lowers the inhibitions and its ´easier´ to hurt yourself in that state.

    A decade or so ago self-harming was so taboo no-one talked about it much. Thankfully people have a better understanding f it these days. It is very common among unhappy young people.

    Yes, it is worrying to see someone doing that - it makes you wonder how bad its going to get... and you feel so helpless as a friend to help them. However, its important to understand that a person self harms as a coping mechanism - not the best coping mechanism there is, but it means at least that a form of coping is going on. It doesn´t necessarily mean the person is going to go on to commit suicide.

    The best you can do for your friend is to try not to freak out or make them feel worse about themselves, explain that you realise they are doing it because they are hurting inside, and encourage them to seek help from a counsellor or doctor, or at least an older person they trust. On a practical level, do some searching around on the net, google self-harm and learn what you can about it, maybe identify some support groups your friend could approach. Lastly, keep your first aid skills up to scratch and know what to do with a bleeding person.

    Sadly a lot of self-harmers find they need to ´cut deeper´ later on to get the same feelings of relief - that´s what makes it dangerous, its a addiction of sorts. That´s why its important to get them to seek help early on.

    Some techniques that recovering self harmers use include snapping a rubber band against their skin - its painful but safer - and drawing on themselves with red marker pen to imitate blood and self destruction without actually breaking the skin, do you think your friend could do this instead?

    Good luck, and remember to take care of your own feelings first - there is only so much a person can do when intense stuff is going on.

  • 5 years ago

    Over the last five years I had begun to have increasingly withdraw into a downward spiral of depression..

    But now with the method I can fully focus my energy and thoughts into a decisive line on how to make my life better constantly. And it works like magic! I'm beginning to attract people to me once again and things have just been looking up since then.

    Helping you eliminate depression?

  • 5 years ago

    Individuals have real problems and genuine modification they desire to make, your issue is real and this is method you need a genuine option. You need to think that you in fact have a way to begin making the modifications in your life. This is where this guide Manifestation Miracle that you can discover here https://tr.im/qGTxV excels because, if your life isn't the life that you want, isn't really ideal YOU Can Possibly Do something making it your method.

    In this guide you aren't taught anything wonderful about Manifestation. Rather you're taught the methods you require to think in order to alter the environment around you. When you change your environment, you're able to alter your conditions. Changing your conditions indicates altering your conditions. When you alter your scenario you change your ideas and this is turn will lead to different habits on your part. This various habits is going to help you to cause all sorts of modification that will draw particular things to you like never ever in the past.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Self harming is usually done when people feel that aspects of their life are out of their control. They self harm because the pain can make them feel as though they have gained control of their lives. It is quite serious and depression could certainly cause this. Your friend needs to seek expert advice but this can only be done when your friends See's themselves as having a problem that needs support.

  • 5 years ago

    Individuals have real issues and genuine change they desire to make, your issue is real and this is method you need a real solution. You require to feel like you really have a method to start making the modifications in your life. This is where this guide Manifestation Miracle that you can discover here https://tr.im/xgQ73 excels because, if your life isn't really the life that you want, isn't ideal YOU CAN do something making it your method.

    In this guide you aren't taught anything wonderful about Manifestation. Instead you're taught the methods you have to believe in order to alter the environment around you. When you alter your environment, you're able to change your conditions. Changing your conditions indicates changing your conditions. When you alter your scenario you change your ideas and this is turn will result in various behavior on your part. This various behavior is going to help you to cause all sorts of modification that will draw particular things to you like never ever before.

  • holt
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    over the final 5 years I had all started to have an increasing style of withdraw right into a downward spiral of melancholy.. yet now with the technique i'm able to totally concentration my capability and ideas right into a decisive line on the thank you to make my existence better consistently. And it works like magic! i'm putting out to attraction to people to me as quickly as back and issues have in basic terms been looking up on the grounds that then. helping you get rid of melancholy?

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.