Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Can an employer fire someone who injures themselves off the job and cannot perform all job duties required?

My friend was hired at a new job and was fully capable of performing her job duties. She then broke her arm in 4 places required rod inplant and screws. She has gone back to work and is now having a problem with her employer. She has been told last week that she will now be expected to work 77 plus hours a week. By 5 hours each day she is in tears, the employer considers this unexcusable absence. I suggested asking her doctor to define her long term disability. She is afraid that the employer will now fire her, even though she can get a tremendous amount of work done while she is there. Their stance is hours worked (salary) not job accuracy and completion.

Any suggestions?

Update:

Hi Judy, thank you for your input, there are so many people who ask questions that might not be aswered correctly. I did go on line again to question your answer regarding disability. I found this web site. it is a bit confusing, but i do believe it might answer you questions.

"The individual with a disability is in the sick role under the medical model. When people are sick, they are excused from the normal obligations of society: going to school, getting a job, taking on family responsibilities, etc. They are also expected to come under the authority of the medical profession in order to get better. Thus, until recently, most disability policy issues have been regarded as health issues, and physicians have been regarded as the primary authorities in this policy area"

Your prompt and educated answer is truly appreciated.

To others responding, I sense your fear of the potential of being terminated. Your knowledge and concern is a blessing.

Tabitha

10 Answers

Relevance
  • hr4me
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    If a person can not perform the essential functions of the job then an employer can let them go. And if you live in an "at-will" state the employer can let her go with or without cause. (They don't even have to tell her the reason why they are letting her go)

    It would probably be best for her to start looking for another job as she is not going to be able to maintain those kinds of hours in light of her injury. And it's not worth her possibly injuring herself further by trying to do it as well.

    Employers can set the work hours for their employees, and they can require that they work long hours as long as they are being paid for all hours worked.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Yes. Being injured on the job and off the job are two very different things. Being injured off the job, you have no protection against being fired. If you can not do the job you were hired for your company can legally let you go. An employer can demand by law, if they wanted to, that an employee work up to 12 hours a day. Her being declared as having a disability will not save her job, and it is not something one doctor can do. To be considered disabled she needs to prove that her disability will last for more than a year, see at least 3 specialist and go to many interviews with the state to be declared disabilied. It is not easy and in the end, even if declared disabled, she will spend even more years trying to get disability.

  • sones
    Lv 4
    4 years ago

    Injured Off The Job

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    Okay, I'm about to be blunt and probably make some people think I'm a rude you-know-what, but I am sick and tired of people feeling ENTITLED to certain things in this world. Good grief, he isn't asking you or the others to do something illegal, or even unreasonable! He is asking for you to wash the chips. People in today's society have gotten to the point where they believe the employer should be grateful to have them as an employee. The fact is, you should be grateful to have a job! Just like someone else above said, have you seen the news? Have you been paying attention? There are people who would crawl over you to have the privilige of being paid to WASH POKER CHIPS! You have no idea how many walk ins we get at my business with people wanting to know if we're hiring. People who are out pounding the pavement in hopes of finding a minimum wage job, much less one with tips! I'm sad every time I have to look in their faces and tell them we aren't hiring right now. Now those are the people who would be grateful to have a job. For goodness sake, get over yourself, or quit and just TRY to file for unemployment. See what happense then.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Judy
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Yes they can. If the person was injured on the job, they'd probably be eligible for workers comp. But since this was an off the job injury, it's not the employer's responsibility to deal with.

    What do you think a doctor declaring her disabled would do? That wouldn't save her job, or necessarily get her any disability benefits.

  • 1 decade ago

    I don't think the employer is actually allowed to make her work that many hours in a week. I also think her doctor should specify what kind of work she is capable of, and for how many hours at a time she can work.

    However, I don't believe any employer is legally required to keep an employee who cannot do the job, for whatever reason. Check to see if she is in an employment at will state.

    It sounds to me like the employer is trying to get her to quit, rather than fire her.

  • 1 decade ago

    Have her doctor write a very detailed description explaining that she may need light duty work due to her arm. I work for an attorney and deal with this kinda stuff all the time, they cannot fire her as long as she has a slip from the doctor. If she doesn't then they have every right to fire her do to lack of production on her part.

  • Viv'
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    It depends what state you live in. In Texas it's an at will state, which means they can fire you whenever, for whatever reason. What she needs to do is go to the HR department with a Dr's note, and ask if there is another job she can do to accommodate her needs. If they can not then they will dismiss her, but she'll qualify for unemployment compensation due to the company terminating her.

  • 1 decade ago

    77 hours of work every week is abusive and should be reported. If however she was hired within 90-180 days before he had this problem then yes she can probably be terminated as this is usually the probation period.

  • 5 years ago

    you are in an auto accident and break your back you are in the hospital nad then your employer fires you on your first day in the hospital is this legal? in the state of Montana

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.