Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Kid antagonizing dogs at the dog park?
Over the weekend we had an unpleasant experience with an unsupervised kid at our favorite dog park. The boy was about 9 or 10 years old, and his parents had let him go do his own thing. The boy was making really loud noises at the dogs, chasing them, trying to pull tails, taking toys away, etc. My dog is a gentle giant with seemingly endless patience, but when the boy wouldn't quit chasing him and shouting he growled. My dog's tail was tucked between his legs and he was noticeably frightened; that's why he was running away from the kid. When he finally growled, my husband told the boy "Please stop. The dog is scared, and growling is his way of telling you to leave him alone. It's not going to be his fault if he bites you." The boy said we were mean and then went somewhere else.
Questions:
Would a dog owner be legally responsible for a dog bite if the kid was provoking the dog? (with this kid, it seems inevitable)
Should we have found the parents and told them about the incident?
Yes, you're right. In retrospect we should have stopped it sooner. But, we don't have kids and weren't really sure how/when it would be appropriate to correct a child we didn't know. If it ever happens again, we'll know to deal with the problem first and worry about someone being offended later.
14 Answers
- 1 decade agoFavorite Answer
man, this makes me so mad....i don't know about the legality of the situation but I would check it out with a lawyer to be sure...
THIS IS WHY KIDS GET BIT & I can guarantee that the parents would have blamed your dog if it bit the kid (which is what the kid deserves)
If I was in that situation I would have gone to the kids parents and told him how unsafe it was to let him roam unsupervised in the park.
The dog park is for DOGS, not kids (our dog park has a sign that says no children under 10 PERIOD)
Once, a man was at our dog park with his daughter, she was about 7 or so, and I think he was a single father and he just brought his daughter to play with the dogs. (Like it was a petting zoo or something). Now, my dog is fine with other dogs, but this girl was kneelling down and wrapping her arms around all these strange dogs!!!!! I explained to the man that my dog was kind of fearful of strangers (which she is) and he shouldnt let his daughter do that to my dog. He seemed suprised that there could be a potential problem, and I further explained that while the dogs at the park might be dog socialized, they might not all be people (especially , children) socialized. He just didn't think about it.
If you approach the parents, with out telling them what an A** their kid is, and word it like, not all dogs here are kid friendly. it might work
Good Luck
- AniLv 41 decade ago
It all depends on which states you live in.
In Wisconsin for example, the owner is responsible for any injuries from a dog bite, unless the victim was taunting the dog or trespassing.
You would have to do a search for your states laws.
I, personally, would have found the parents and explained to them what happened when their "lovely" little boy was torturing the dogs and told them not to be surprised if he doesn't wound up bit.
It is irresponsible, rude and idiotic of those parents to allow their child to run amok like that in an area where there are so many unknown dogs.
Your husband was way nicer than I ever would have been with the little brat.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Yes, a dog owner is legally responsible if a dog bites anyone, no matter the circumstances. I would have found the kid's parents and told them not only because it was scary for the animals but for his own protection, too. Chances are they had no idea he was acting that way and would have stopped it. At age 9-10 he should know better!
- Nekkid Truth!Lv 71 decade ago
ussually the dog park has posted laws/rules about leaving children in a dog park unattended. If the parents were no where in sight, I would have called the authorities, or whomever is in charge of the park.
I dont know who would be responsible here.. the kid should not be unattended, but at the same time, you are responsible for controlling your dog... even if it means removing your dog from the situation before it gets bad. If an incident did happen, it may just depend on the judge.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- LionessLv 61 decade ago
Yes, you can be legally responsible. This is part of the reason I'm "that mean lady that lives over there" to the kids in my neighborhood. I don't care who's fun I'm wrecking - I don't like kids in the first place and I'm NOT willing to put up with their crap.
That INCLUDES fireworks in my neighborhood. If I hear ONE firework and it is not the 4th of July, I will give ONE warning, the next call goes to the police. There is no reason my dog should have to suffer because of people's stupidity.
One thing that would have been a good idea is for you to call your dog to you so you could handle it right near you. (If your dog doesn't have a solid recall, that would be something to work on - for this kind of thing, and many others) My dog knows without a doubt that if he is even in an uncomfortable situation to come to me, and if he doesn't - I will call him, so I can handle it right in my presence.
If you saw the parents, you definitely should have talked to them, but if you didn't see them or know who they are that's difficult to do. Your biggest concern should be your own dog.
- dmg1969Lv 51 decade ago
I work in a law firm and I have to say that, unfortunately, you would probably be liable. Plaintiff attorneys will always find an angle. "Well, you could have left the park with your dog" "Well, you're an adult and he is only a child" "Well, you could have told the parents"...and on and on.
I know what I would LIKE to happen had the kid been bitten...the parents tell him he was in the wrong and beaten his *** on top of the dog biting him! Chances are though that the kid's behavior is an indication of what kind of parents he has.
- •Poppy•Lv 71 decade ago
It's like the movie Dumbo all over again, so sad....
I'm not sure if it is going to be legally your problem, I would certainly hope not. But sometimes the parents cry a different way, and you need a good lawyer.
And yes, you should have. They might not have had any idea of what their child was doing (even though it was silly to leave him alone). Couldnt hurt to say something, especially if it is a reoccurring thing.
- ?Lv 45 years ago
No. All doggies is additionally be knowledgeable if effectively professional. notwithstanding, to in basic terms adjust to instructions from the books jointly as they are no longer working isn't the surprising answer. each and every domestic dog has a character and demands coaching consistent with that. you may seek for suggestion a domestic dog behaviourist. And take her on many many walks (each and every couple of hours or so) till she pees and poops, and compliment her jointly as she does that for the duration of the process your walk, just so she would be in a position to get used to it. Spanking a domestic dog continuously produces the choice result than what you go with. I comprehend individuals lose their endurance, notwithstanding it incredibly is different to steer her to peeing interior continuously. And for a jointly as, a minimum of, do no longer in simple terms assume her to be knowledgeable to go out on her own. you may take her on walks often, jointly as you have faith it's time to pee, for extremely a jointly as. after which you will have the potential to make the walks much less often (4 in accordance to day) and then 3. yet she demands to be walked for a jointly as. She's now no longer a cat!
- 1 decade ago
1. It's quite possible that you could be found liable, since it's your word against the kid's, and people tend to favor the kid since he's the one with the injury.
2. I'd have chased the little brat off a lot sooner, and I don't give a chit if he thinks I'm "mean". You have to protect your dog, there's no reason to stand by and let him be tormented, he may form negative associations with kids.
- 1 decade ago
Wow, that is awful! The kid should have known better! Although the kid is a brat, it is still by law the dog's fault if bitten. My thought is to tell the kid to take you to his parents, and explain to them what he did, and if need be call the cops, it isn't your job to raise this kid, and it shouldn't be. He would've learned his lesson!!