Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Should they consider White Americans as being of Native American descent?

I am of Cherokee descent, which goes back ten generations ago. My family is mostly white, but I still consider myself to be a mixture of Native American and European, Should they consider people, such as me not just European, but also Native American descent like the Mestizos (Spanish and Native Americans descent)?

13 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    As far as I'm concerned, YES. If anyone has American Indians in their genealogy then they should be considered to be American Indian. I do not like the use of "Native American". Anyone born here is "Native American". Our ancestors were American Indians and were on the North American continent thousands of years prior to the Europeans Invasion and Occupation. I'm of mixed ancestry and the more I learn of my genealogy the more I realize that I have very little white ancestry. So when I'm filling out forms I check American Indian as my race. All of my ancestry is special too me, but it's my American Indian ancestry is he most important too me.

  • 1 decade ago

    Just remember this:

    It's not the quantity of Native American blood that flows through your veins, but the quality of it. Your pride in being part of a great culture and heritage.

    And don't listen to those who say you can't be Native American unless you are part of a recognized tribe. If you have ancestors that were Native American then you can consider yourself Native American. But you cannot legally claim to be Native American unless you are a member of a Federally Recognized Tribe or Nation. So you can't check the Native American, or American Indian box on any applications or other legal documents..

    I have to ask though, you claim 10 generations of Cherokee ancestry, if that is so are you trying to gain membership in one of the Cherokee Nations? If you can find your ancestors on one of the rolls IE: The Dawes Roll for the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma or the Baker Roll for the Eastern Band of Cherokee, then you can begin the process of becoming a member of the Nation. The Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma no longer requires a blood quantum to qualify for membership, you only have to prove you descend from someone on the Dawes Roll. The Eastern Band still requires 1/8 (I think) blood quantum.

    Source(s): enrolled tribal member
  • 1 decade ago

    Yes , They consider You what You considere yourself...

    = D You are a white American Girl of European and Native American descent

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I think it should really be about what you identify with. I would guess an overwhelming majority of white Americans that have had families here since before the 1900's have at least one Native American ancestor. But...if you ancestor existed 10 generations ago, its not likely you identify much with the Cherokee culture, nor that you carry much of her Cherokee genes. So....no....I do not think white Americans with Native American ancestry should be considered Native by default.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    “Native American” is a PC term used to replace “American Indian” by the government. American Indian (Native American) is “JUDICIALLY” defined as a “RACE” for “LEGAL” purposes.

    There are strict requirements both, tribal and governmental that define who is Native American. Unless you meet those requirements you are not Native American.

    If you have no knowledge of the culture, the Native worldview (perspective) or have any involvement in Native American issues and struggles……. what is the point of saying you are Native American?

    There is a lot more to being Native American than just casually spoken words.

    ====================

    EDIT

    Coolrogue… What a contradiction…"you can consider yourself Native American. But you cannot legally claim to be Native American".

    It’s just like saying to a citizen of another country….. you can consider yourself American. But you cannot legally claim to be American.

    That’s just plain crap. Either you are or you are not. PERIOD

    I could consider myself Scandinavian but that does not make me Scandinavian.

    .

  • If you want to claim that, it's part of you and you should feel free. That being said, my grandfather is white so should I consider myself to be of European descent? Most Americans are a great mix of many things and it's what makes us unique. You can claim as much or as little of your ancestry as you want but if we tried to create different categories for every single mixture or even the most common mixtures in this country we would have thousands of racial categories which really isn't efficient.

  • 1 decade ago

    i am extremely pale and of Irish/ Blackfoot decent. my mother and brother are both dark skinned and are often asked if they are native American. but if i say anything about being part (1/2) native American i get all kinds of looks usually from people who don't have a clue but other native Americans always tell me i have all the bone structure and none of the tan.

    if you consider yourself to be a mix of native American and European decent then don't be ashamed of that it's who you are.

  • Indigo
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    It's a tough call, things are so mixed up these days, knowing if your coming or going, definitions and general view points get blurred. *Genetically speaking* I'm both. Culturally speaking I'm neither! Oh my..

    Socially I'm just at the basic level, the nationality, so the most I am in general is American.

  • 1 decade ago

    What part of you is Native American? Your ear? The big toe on your left foot? Your right knee? Your left arm? Or most importantly, your heart?

    If you have the heart, learn the ways and walk the red road, then you are Cherokee. If your learn nothing and do nothing for The People, then you are not.

    Source(s): Member Eastern Lenape Nation and Turtle Island Chautauqua
  • 1 decade ago

    The Caucasians I see say they have native blood but don't look it lol!!!!! The only white person I would give a pass to is Cher

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.