ANTM question. Should a femine man be allowed to participate on the show?

Isis should definitely be allowed to compete. She is better than any of the other girls and seems really nice. She has had to go through so many difficult things in her life and yet she is still super confident and sure of herself and not afraid to go for her dreams. I admire her and can't believe the horrible things all the other girls say about her. They have no idea what she is going through and has been her whole life so they have absolutely no right to say what they say about her.

Did Isis actually undergo a sex-change operation, in which case she is biologically female and therefore would have every right to go on the show, or is he still biologically male but just living as a female? Or does he want gender-reassignment surgery to make him a female, but simply can't afford it yet? Does the 'female' part of the rules mean you've got to have girl parts to go on the show, or does it simply mean you have to identify as being female?

IMO, it all depends on the details of the rules and Isis' current situation. If the rules were unclear (as Isis' biological gender will be extremely clear during the nude photo shoot episode) then the producers had every right in the world to make whatever decision they thought was best. It's not like Isis has any sort of unfair advantage over the other contestants...

Yes she is BIOLOGICALLY male, but has lived her life as a woman since she was a child, I don't know much about gender reassignment surgery but I'm guessing it's not cheap. Isis has every right to live her life as the person she feels she was born to be, that happens to be female. It shows immense courage to discuss her personal life on a national television show. GO ISIS.... The fact that she's a kick *** model is icing on the cake!

Yes i think she has a right to go on ANTM and do her thing. I hate those girls on there who making fun of her, She's a way better model than a lot of the girls that mad it through. GO ISIS!!!

Well, Tula was one of those trans-testicals and s/he made it all the way to modeling shows, runways, and even an appearance on one of the James Bond movies.

Yes, I think she should be allowed to compete.

Is it the womens' portion of the show? If so then, no.

If he/she has a dyck she/he should not be allowed.