Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Copyright claim on Youtube?

okay, so i made a video/slideshow for my girlfriend for her birthday...you know, pics of her from when she was little all the way until she was 18. and i had music in the background. anyway, so yeah, i uploaded it on youtube (by her request, cuz she wanted it so she could put it on her myspace and friendster), and a couple months later, it gets deleted!!! wtf!!! i try the url and it says that the video is "no longer available due to copyright claim by a third party"

wtf does that supposed to mean???? when I MADE THE SLIDESHOW! BY SCRATCH! i used windows movie maker and added pics and music in the background...no body else made it but me >__<

2 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I regret to inform you that any music which is not your creation

    and used as part of your video is indeed copyright infringement.

    Companies like UMG, Warner and Viacom not only "own" their

    music, they also "own" the rights to them, which includes how

    and where the music can be publicly presented and performed.

    Thus they would be 100% within their rights to claim the music

    in your video as their own -- especially if you didn't seek written

    permission or a licence to use it and "broadcast" it on YouTube.

    They could easily force YouTube to take your video "off the air"

    (potentially banning you) for any number of reasons:

    1) If you used "their music", it's considered part of that famous

    sentence "unauthorized duplication, whether in whole or in part,

    without the expressed written consent of...." Their fear wouldn't

    just be about you, but also other people who could conceivably

    download, copy or listen to the music without having bought it.

    2) You are potentially lessening the value of "their property" by

    presenting and "broadcasting" it in a bad-quality, tiny 4x3-inch,

    bad-resolution, monophonic-sounding and possibly amateurish

    setting.

    3) They may think your video makes "their property" look either

    bad, cheap or unappealing to somebody who may otherwise be

    considering purchasing "their music".

    4) They could also be thinking that anyone's memory or mental

    image of "their music" could forever be "haunted" by images of

    your video or your YouTube channel if they feel it's in bad taste.

    Even if you were to give credit on your video to the music label,

    the artist or the music itself, that should never be construed as

    a validation, excuse or justification for you (and really YouTube)

    to "break the law". You can always claim that your video is "for

    personal use only", but then a very intriguing question might be

    why did you put your video on YouTube? And how/why did you

    steal "their music"?

    As for the other people who may be uploading the same music,

    either YouTube will get to them eventually or somebody who is

    jealous will "flag" their video. If you're willing to take the chance

    and reupload your video with the same music, avoid writing the

    name of the song or the artist in either your title, description or

    tags. Also, don’t use sentences like "no copyright infringement

    intended", "I do not own the song" or "I don't take any credit for

    the music". YouTube's computers search for phrases like that.

    Also, please bear in mind that the music industry is beginning

    to use hidden or inaudible "digital watermarks" or "fingerprints"

    to uncover and identify the illicit use of their music. As such, it

    is possible that no matter how often you try to upload your vid,

    it will always be rejected for reasons of copyright infringement.

    You might have to find a different recording of the music which

    you want to use.

    I hope my info has been helpful to you.

  • 1 decade ago

    who made the music? Unless you have a recording studio in your basement and recorded the song by yourself and created the beat with MIDI or electronic instruments, then the song is not yours.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.