Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Need ideas on training a difficult puppy?
We got her when she was 7 months old and she had no training at all.
We have 2 older dogs, one is very old and the other is 6, they are all beagles. They are both very well behaved. All are adopted and all are female.
She came to us with a crate which we don't have much use for except for when we leave the house without her.
I have tried everything to get her to stop going in the garbage, chasing the cat and going wild when she gets fed.
I have tried to get her to sit and she just won't do it! She has been here for 2 months now. I used positive reinforcement to teach her to go outside and that was a breeze. I know that the rest of the bad behaviors would be fixed if I could have her sit when I tell her too. She sees the other two listening to us and I thought that would help.
I have tried to use treats but she goes nuts trying to get the food and doesn't listen. I have also tried without treats. I have spent more than ample time with her on a daily basis. She even tries to take treats out of the other 2 dogs mouths!
She was purchased in September by a friend, she couldn't train her so she went to someone else. Then she wound up at my mother's until we could bring her to our house. She has been here long enough to have settled down.
The last two dogs I had as puppies by this age would sit and wait until I said OK to even go to their bowls and had mastered many other commands.
The only other thing she knows is to come when I call her.
As far as the cat goes, she gets scratched on a regular basis and she just keeps going back for more. If I call the cat or say her name the puppy comes bounding up in her face so I can hardly spend any quality time with the cat who has no problem with the other 2 dogs.
She is very stubborn...typical beagle, I know.
Any tips would be great. My only other idea is obedience school.
I can't decide which answer is best, it is a toss up between Maria L and Peggy Swager.
Thanks to both of you, I will be using ideas from both of you and plan to buy your book Peggy
7 Answers
- Anonymous1 decade agoFavorite Answer
Until you said Beagle, I was guessing this was a Jack Russell Terrier. This dog has obviously taken charge. You can be calm and assertive, but the dog will only walk off and get into mischief, leaving you standing there. You need to take back control a little at a time.
I am glad the dog crates. That can give you a place to begin your reform training. Do this exercise when you have a lot of time. Put the dog in the crate. Get down to her eye level. The moment the dog looks away from the handle where you let her out, immediately praise and let her out. Give her a treat and put her back end. Again wait for her to look towards you. After a couple of times, you can ask for her to make eye contact before you let her out. This becomes the cornerstone of reform.
When doing this the first time, don’t be surprised if the exercise takes a very long time. You will also need to repeat it a few times until she realizes that for her to get what she wants, she has to look at you first.
If she paws and whines to get out of the crate, then you first need to modify that habit. Let her paw and whine, but don’t reprimand. Really concentrate and wait for that instant that she takes a pause in that behavior. Immediately say “good” and let her out. Give her a treat. You may even try throwing a ball or using a squeak toy to give a little play as a reward for earning her way out of the crate.
I have an article I wrote which was nominated for an award this year from DWAA. This tells has more ideas on how do reform training with a dog such as yours. Email me with your email address and I will send it to you.
Oh and by the way, seven months isn't a puppy, you have a full blown adolescent.
Peggy Swager
APDT-Behaviorist
author of Training the Hard to Train Dog
www.peggyswager.com
Source(s): Training the Hard to Train Dog - Anonymous1 decade ago
Beagles aren't stubborn...they have a hidden agenda. They don't listen because they lack proper motivation, training plan that uses force, they don't understand what you are asking, or they can't make the proper 'decisions' and need more leadership. No matter the situation, all dogs deserve to be treated with respect and trained without any unnecessary force or pain. This does for choke chains, e-collars, prongs, yelling, hitting...etc.
It sounds like your dog in this situation needs proper leadership. Try nothing in life is free. This program shows the dog that they aren't in charge, and they have to work for everything, from pets, food, walks and play.
For her grabbing treats:
Get some boring treats (cheerios or kibble) and sit on the floor. Let her sniff your hand, but the minute she whines, barks, starts to paw...etc. stand up, turn around and ignore her. The minute she offers non-obssessive behavior, like sniffing on the floor, turning away or something like that, give her the treat. Do this for a couple days until she leaves you alone about the treats. Gradually start moving up the yumminess for something like cheese or liver. Repeat this. Only train this for a week or so. This, in combination of NILIF, shows her you're in control of every aspect of her life, and she needs to listen to you too.
For the cats & garbage:
This is how I trained an awesome 'leave it' as well as control around other animals (besides dogs, lol, but that's another issue).
I put my border collie Joy on a long line and put the cat in the middle of the room. The second she started fixating on the cat, barking, or lunging, I made the line taut (I didn't pull her back, but made it tight). For this type of training, I made her think a little. She had to figure out what I was asking. I let her bark all she wanted, lunge, growl, what ever. But the minute the line went slack, and she looked at me, I clicked (she's clicker trained) and gave her a treat. It may take a few times, but she'll start to associate her looking at you or not reacting to the cat with getting a treat. Do this a few times a day. Once she's solid with connecting the taut leash with looking at you, start saying 'leave it' right as she looks at the cat and make the line taut. Now she's connecting the word, the taut line, and the cat with looking back at you. Don't forget LOTS of treats and praise! When she's good at the verbal, you can try this off leash. Keep practicing, and be diligent! This is a behavior that's difficult to break, but it will happen.
*For the garbage, do this exercise, except replace the cat with the garbage*
These are my favorite training sites, and I hope they help your doggy insight no matter what training style. :)
http://www.hsus.org/pets/pet_care/our_pets_for_lif...
http://www.clickertraining.com/
http://www.trulydogfriendly.com/blog/?page_id=2
http://www.positivedogtraining.org/
1 more thing to remember- not all dogs are the same, and training styles will vary!
Source(s): experience! - Anonymous5 years ago
Hi, I understand that you are looking for some advice or resources to help fully train your dog or fix behavior problems. If a professional dog trainer is not an option at this time, or if you want to trt training your dog on your own (a great way to bond), I'd suggest you https://bitly.im/aMd7K
A friend recommened it to me a few years ago, and I was amazed how quickly it worked, which is why I recommend it to others. The dog training academy also has as an excellent home training course.
- ?Lv 45 years ago
I have a Border Collie and they are very hypper. I started her in Puppy Training at PetsMart, when she was 5 months old. I was very glad I did. It only cost me $100. for the 8 weeks, once a week. The lady I had was very good. My dog is 2 yrs now and walks beside me and doesn't bark at cars or people anymore. As for chewing on things take away the item and give him/her a toy in place of it and say "leave it" and they will learn very fast.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- 1 decade ago
The best thing you could possibly do for you and the dog is to get into obedience classes. They teach you how to train your dog. This is not meant to be insulting, but helpful. Any dog is only as good as the training it receives and you could really use the help of a professional. Good luck.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
NOT the dog....YOUR fault!
Your weak,sloppy ,random attempts at training are making no impression at all.The dog needs a firm hand & a strict schedule of *real* training/discipline. You're just dinking around,half-hearted.
- Tiny DanLv 61 decade ago
you need to be calm and assertive , also you need to be dominant , watch the dog whisperer a couple times that stuff works wonders
www.dogwhisperer.com
***sorry glorianne , i did not know you wanted a 1000 word answer
*** peggy , getting down to the dogs eye level is the exact wrong thing to do , i can not believe you are here passing yourself off as an expert