Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

skeptic asked in Politics & GovernmentPolitics · 1 decade ago

Can someone please explain to me what the Gazans and Hamas were thinking?

READ THIS CAREFULLY: I am not pretending to be knowledgeable about this issue.

But could anyone please explain to me how in the world Arabs could even pretend to be outraged about Israel attacking Hamas and Gaza after they launched rockets at Israel for a week? What on earth did they think Israel would do, just stand by and watch the fireworks display?

I am not the kind of person who thinks Israel is always blameless (they have done their share of wrongdoing). But I can not see how Hamas breaking the cease-fire was anything but their own fault. Even the Palestinian President has said this is the fault of Hamas.

Are they just trying to get sympathy from other Arabs? What could they be thinking? Could anyone explain this to me?

Please, no nonsense about how Israel controls Gaza (they left years ago) or how they shouldn't retaliate with such force (that would be like saying the man that you tried to kill with a baseball bat was too brutal because he shot you after you took a few swings at him).

Intelligent thought please.

Thanks

Update:

EDIT: Frank, you may be right. But is it not the responsibility of the Gazans to police their own country?

Update 2:

otto: would you care to explain that, or just leave it as nonsense?

Update 3:

krollohare2: thank you for trying. That is an interesting idea.

Update 4:

tabbi840... also good thoughts - thank you.

Update 5:

Frank (I gave you a thumbs up) I see what you're saying, and you have a good point. But a murder can be committed by anyone with just a house hold knife, or a gun manufactured in the U.S. Rockets on the other hand are rather complex and are being brought in from other countries (presumably through one boarder in the south). Is is not in the ability of Gaza to police that boarder?

[This is a genuine question; I really don't know the answer.]

Update 6:

otto (?) I don't know enough about the blockade but I believe the incident was the one where the 5 children were killed??? The way to deal with that (weather it was a mistake or not) is not to launch rockets and then act surprised when Israel retaliates.

11 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Very simple. Hamas is a terrorist group.

    As far as justification. I don't always agree with Obama, in fact I disagree with a lot of his now-changed platforms. But one thing he said did make sense. When he was in Jerusalem a few months back, he said something like, "If someone was shooting rockets into my house, hurting my kids, I'd have to fire back at them."

    The fact of the matter is, Hamas is stirring up trouble with Israel because they're professional terrorists, manipulating the ignorant masses of the Gaza Strip, and doing this for profit. They use the civilian population as human shields, and the civilian population lets them do that.

    How? My theory is simple. They've been supported by the other Arab states and Iran. Those oil producing countries need the price of oil to shoot up. If it does, Hamas will continue to get the "donations" it needs to make more rockets and buy and smuggle more guns into Gaza.

    Therefore, by attacking Israel for a week and instigating a retaliation to make them stop, they have artificially generated a crisis, which they had hoped would spike the price of oil up.

    Instead, oil went flat for the most part.

    Hence, it did not work. Now, Israel is threatening to level the Gaza Strip.

    Personally, I think they'd be justified in razing the whole area, house by house, building by building, detonating and caving in tunnels, bunkers, etc. and obliterating Hamas as a military force.

    Once they do that, then the Gazans can rebuild, this time terrorist-free.

    If they remain quiet and peaceful, and demilitarize, then Israel has no reason to do anything with them except conduct commerce and trade.

    But if they want a technical state of war, progress, improvement, and trade are impossible.

  • 1 decade ago

    Not to "defend" Palestine, but I think there was something about a blockade, and Israel coming over the borders, and looking for a tunnel into Israel? Something like that. But, yeah, how does indiscriminately firing into Israel accomplish ANYTHING? it doesn't. It would have been better if they were to have been protesting the blockades and posting them on YouTube, and getting the world media's attention before firing rockets into Israel, don't you think?

    What Hamas has accomplished is even EGYPT is cutting them off now....one of their supporters..

    edit: frank is wrong. Israel is trying to get civilians out of teh way by dropping leaflets and calling civilians on cell phones, also, Hamas was VOTED in by Palestinians.

    .

    The hatred needs to stop, I don't care who stops it first, but someone needs to be the bigger man, and the other side needs to respect it.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Please, no nonsense about how Israel controls Gaza (they left years ago) or how they shouldn't retaliate with such force (that would be like saying the man that you tried to kill with a baseball bat was too brutal because he shot you after you took a few swings at him).

    Intelligent thought please.

    when you dont use intelligent thought how can you expect anyone else to?

    well first of all blockading the place is hardly leaving. and do you really think bombing the **** out of everything knowing theres civilians there is justified to a rocket that killed 4 people. hamas shouldnt be firing rockets but what choice do they have. israel refuses (against international law) to stop the blockade, cuts off electricity and water supply, broke the ceasefire on november 4th by killing 6 people (google it and theres an atricle on the guardians website about it).if israel just treated people in gaza more humanely maybe the attacks would stop. if they didnt stop then they have a right to kill these terrorists but the fact they wont even attempt peace makes their actions completely inexcuseable

  • ?
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    This is the basic problem with religious ideology. If you read any of the religious books, the bible, the talmud or the koran, they all they the believers that they must kill the apostates and nonbelievers.

    There is really no way to convince these people to stop because they "believe" that their particular book is the literal word of "god" and that if they do what the book tells them, they will go to heaven.

    All of which is really ridiculous nonsense to anyone with a reasonable grip on reality. I don't know if there is any way to get religion out of this crisis, but I really don't think it will ever be solved until that happens.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • bill
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    A thought.Now there's a concept.

    I feel sorry for the everyday people.The trouble here is they "elected" Hamas,and Hamas doesn't care,and got them into a war.Then again we had to put up with 8 years of Bush,and he doesn't care, and he got us into a war.So what country am I in(Damn rum.)?

  • 1 decade ago

    They are trying to gain the sympathy of other arabs and hand-wringing Americans like the answerer above, who claims Israel is indiscriminately killing palestinians. 84% of the palestinians killed so far have not been civilians, according to the AP.

    http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20081230/ap_on_re_mi_ea...

  • Frank
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    probably because the missile attacks were carried out by a small number of individuals, yet Israel is indiscriminately bomb all Palestinians

    edit - please, this argument is so ridiculous. It's like Mexico saying it will attack the US until there are no more murders being committed in the US. They would perpetually attack the US because there will ALWAYS be murders. It's a blanket excuse, because as long as there is just ONE person who is able to shoot a missile or two into Israel, they can bomb Gaza perpetually under that excuse.

  • Lee D
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    They don't think.They only hate,and will not be happy until Israel and every jew is wiped from the face of this earth.

  • 1 decade ago

    My guess is that they are trying to get their muslim cousins from other nations to join them in attacking Israel.

  • 1 decade ago

    I urge Israel to bomb until no one bombs back. If its tit for tat, this crap will never end.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.