2 questions regarding the referral system?

interesting question.

the second scenario, definitely the batsmen can call for the referral, even if he's told to do it by the non-striker. the video will pick up the no-ball in seconds, as it is the first thing checked, and it will be not out.

the first scenario is difficult... i'm unclear on whether the fielding captain can ask for a referral if the umpire calls a no-ball, although it seems as though the captain can challenge any decision in which he believes the umpire made an error. presumably this has to involve a dismissal, but would a dismissal from a no-ball count? good question. luckily, it would be a very rare case. the batsman would have very little time to notice the call, unlike in the old days when no-balls were called on the bowler's back foot, which gave the batsman more time to change his shot. and the odds of an umpire making a front-foot no-ball error, on a very flighted delivery from a spinner, and the batsman changing his stroke to throw the bat at it, and getting out, and a fielder noticing the error, would be astronomical. a spinner bowling a front-foot no-ball is rare enough, let alone the umpire mistakenly thinking he had. it's a good hypothetical question though.

what about shane warne's 99, when he was caught from an obvious front-foot no-ball... i guess there's no way for him to know to ask for a referral. and appealing straight-forward outfield catches would surely be frowned upon if the only possible saviour for the batsman was an uncalled no-ball... but what about if it's the last wicket, and you still have two referrals left? will the batsmen just use it because they can?

consider this can of worms opened.

Well actually in the referral system the first thing the umpire checks for is a no ball so yes a decision can be overturned on a no ball but yes it is unfair to give the batsman out in this way.

Yes the non striker can recommend the batsman he should refer it.

I noticed that during the recent NZ-Windies series that whenever a referral was made, the first thing they did was they checked whether the bowler overstepped or not. Always. I haven't seen any of the South Africa-Aus test, but surely they are doing the same thing. I believe in the 2nd situation the non-striker is allowed to recommend the challenge so the final verdict should be not out.

I'm not sure what would happen in the first situation though, it would probably have to be out, even though it may be unfait.

what form of conventional practitioner did you spot? If it became your nicely-known conventional practitioner then flow to a psychiatrist for a appropriate prognosis.. a nicely-known conventional practitioner isn't qualified to diagnose Bipolar any further than he's to diagnose and take care of maximum cancers. If he suspected maximum cancers he ought to refer you to an oncologist and if he suspected Bipolar he ought to have refered you to a psychiatrist..... Then make an appointment with a psychologist. docs (and psychiatrists) purely relatively take care of the actual factors of it including meds.. you want a psychologist for clinical care. flow with the Bipolar prognosis for now because of the fact coverage firms do no longer pay for psychological well-being subjects different than for bipolar or Schizophrenia.... So - flow get a 2d opinion from a psychiatrist and make an appointment with a psychologist for clinical care..... take the lithium.. despite the fact that while you're nto bipolar it ought to help mutually with your moods.. if after 6 weeks it fairly is not making a diffrence you are able to communicate a distinctive med.

No...no balls cant be refered.

Only dismissals (like normal dismisals, bump ball, catches on boundary) can be reffered.

Its in the ICC playing Handbook. For some reason i cant put the link. check the icc website

referral system used when batsman or bowler or captain have doubt on decision (like LBW, Catch or LBW..) its not apply on NO ball

EDIT:

may be i say wrong.... lets see other answers

No...no balls cant be refered.

Only dismissals (like normal dismisals, bump ball, catches on boundary) can be reffered.

Its in the ICC playing Handbook. For some reason i cant put the link. check the icc website