Football:Todd Mcshay Or Mel Kiper Jr?

Kiper's hair but Todd Mcshay in the total package. He seems to know a lot more and is easier to listen to and has a good personality to go with his football knowledge.

Kiper is like a vampire with the updo, but he can just ramble on sometimes.

FQ: 2nd round , 51st overall

Mel Kiper Jr. Thought about it- Everybody wins.

Mel Kiper Jr, he knows his stuff. Packers are drafting Number 9.

Mel Kiper Jr because he's more passionate about the draft than any other analyst the falcons pick 24th overall.

for some reason, i’ve always held allegiance to Mel Kiper Jr. hair jokes aside, he’s always seemed to have a good read on most players, though saying Reggie Bush carried the Saints to the NFC championship game is an obvious omission of Drew Brees’ efforts. whatever. it was a quick "off the cuff" statement.

FQ: my team (Patriots) is drafting #22.

Kiper can be annoying. But he clearly works hard at what he does and his heart is into it. For that, I respect him.

McShay is not annoying; and it's fun to listen to what happens when he and Mel disagree.

The Cowboys have 11 picks but don't start until #51 in the second round.

If I had to choose between the two of them I would pick Kiper. He really get into what he is doing and is passionate about it. He also has more experience the McShay.

My favorite NFL draft guy is Mike Mayock of NFL Network.

BQ: Bengals have the 6th pick.

Im gonna go Mel Kiper. He has definately been the most consistent.

I hate Kiper. He over rates the players HE thinks will do good in the NFL and their not even that good. When Jay Cutler got drafted he said Jay was overrated and that Vince young and Matt leinart will be great pros. He was so right about that one huh? Thats just one example, he also though Alex smith would be the next steve young for the 49ers, though Jamarcus Russel was the right guy for the raiders and so on. I don't even listen to him anymore.

Bears dont have a first round pick

Todd because i don't want to know how long it takes Kiper Jr to fix that hair