Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
grammar questions for grammarians only.. read the sentence?
Is it "Whom are you acting for?" or "Who are you acting for?"
i'd usually say "who are you acting for?" but then it seems that who is the one who's receiving the action and thus the object of of the verb are so it should be whom? right? But if i said "For whom are you acting?" it would be absolutely correct. Please shed some more light on the subject. tell me which is correct and why. best answer is ten point.
i know google is there. i usually would google but i would like to hear the thoughts about the subject from other people interested in proper grammar.
3 Answers
- 1 decade agoFavorite Answer
All pronouns have a case, except for the pronouns This, That, These, Those, and Which. These do not change form.
There are three cases: possessive, nominative, and objective.
Because the pronoun we are discussing is not possessing anything, WHOSE can be ignored.
In your sentence, the best option is FOR WHOM ARE YOU ACTING?
This is the objective case, because it is the object of the preposition FOR. This is the best option because some grammarians dislike a preposition being at the end of a clause.
The second best is WHOM ARE YOU ACTING FOR?
This is more confusing because it looks like the pronoun WHOM is the subject of a linking verb ARE. If this were so, then it would be WHO. But it only looks like ARE is a linking verb because it is in question form, so the ARE precedes YOU instead of follows it. If it were written in declarative form, which is the best form to determine a pronoun's case, then it is clear that ARE is in fact a helping verb, not a linking verb, so WHOM is not nominative case.
The third option is incorrect; however, whom is slowly becoming obsolete, and thus this option is regularly used.
- pat zLv 71 decade ago
"For whom are you acting?" is the grammatically correct question.
Who is the subjective pronoun, whom is its objective form.
'You' is the subject, 'are acting' the verb (with participle), 'whom' is the object of the preposition 'for'.
That said, it is becoming more common to use who in place of whom (as in "Who does she think she's kidding?")
In your example, think of the Ernest Hemingway book For Whom the Bell Tolls.
Source(s): English classes eons ago and the internet (google "who/whom" and read away!). - 1 decade ago
Whom--
The pronoun in this case is recieving the action of the sentence, so you go with the "object" pronoun, whom.