Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Anonymous
Anonymous asked in Society & CultureReligion & Spirituality · 1 decade ago

Why is anti-Catholic bigotry acceptable in modern society?

Really, even self proclaimed rational people seem to jump on the anti-Catholic boat. I just don't get it. You would think the progressive attitudes that have changed the mainstream point of view of minorities and women would extend to the age old hatred of Catholicism and Catholics. But is hasn't. Or it doesn't seem to have. Many of the same bigoted statements used in the past during the Christian persecutions and Protestant Reformation are still used to this day here on Yahoo.

Look, I'm not saying that the Catholic Church is above criticism. Surly, it is accptable, and even justified to be critical of the Church. But is seems as though anti-Catholicism is among the most accptable forms of bigotry. Any ideas on why this may be?

(Note: I draw a line between criticism and bigotry. I understand being critical of the Catholic Church, I am fine with that. I am talking about the irrational hatred of Catholics. Calling them the "Whores of Babylon" or the "Anti-Christ" or a bunch of "child molesters" is beyond rational critique.)

Update:

On a further note, can you compair the bigotry towards Catholics with the current bigotry towards Muslims? How might they be similer, how might they be different?

Update 2:

Also, I am not really condeming people who are anti-Catholic. I may want bigotry to stop, but more than anything, I am trying to understand their point of view.

Update 3:

Once again, I clearly stated it is acceptable, sometimes even justifiable to "disagree" or be critical of Catholicism. Im not talking about that, I am talking about bigotry.

Update 4:

Chariot's point is well taken and I accept certin truths held within it. Sure, as a Catholic, I am naturaly more interested in Catholic issues. However, anti-Catholicism is a very real issue and has been an unfortunate part of American history from the very beginning. Much of the bigotry against the Irish and Italian imagrants in the 19th and early 20th centuries were fueled by anti-Catholicism. Even John F. Kennedy had to justify his Catholicism before being elected into office.

So sure, I may exaggerate it to a point. Thats what humans do. But it is a very real problem.

Update 5:

PARTYMARTY is a prime example:

" I do not think of the catholic people but the clergy are the ones to whom all the hatred should go."

Why should hate go anywhere. I mean, thats like someone in the Civil Rights movements saying, "I dont hate black people, I just hate the people who represent and lead them." That is still bigorty. That is still a horrible point of view which spreads hatred.

This brings me back to my question, why is it acceptable to say things like, " I do not think of the catholic people but the clergy are the ones to whom all the hatred should go."

I mean, if I were to say, " I do not think of the Jewish people but the Rabbis are the ones to whom all the hatred should go." You would all agree that I am a monster......AND RIGHTLY SO. That would be a monsterous thing to say.

Update 6:

Gemisitc2004 really takes the cake here.

"But I have to wonder if Catholics ever really considered why most of their own fellow Christians are critical of their practices."

I mean, I can just imagine southern plantation owners discussing racisim over dinner, asking a slave, "Have you ever bothered to consider why we have enslaved you. Or why we hate you?"

Are you insinuating that Catholics DESERVE bigotry? As if I should appologize for my Catholicism. "Gee, I am sorry my brothers and sisters in Christ that I am Catholic. I will try not to accept the sacraments or honor Mary any more."

Maybe your right, we deserve your slandar. Wow, that is a whole new level of missguided.

26 Answers

Relevance
  • Favorite Answer

    I have calmed down on my criticisms of the Catholic church, mainly because I have seen way too many people start skewing the truth, or telling bold faced lies about the church.... and then bringing me along for the ride.

    But I'm not a bigot if I see that the Catholic church is the closest one to the definition given of the anti-christ's church. That doesn't mean for sure that it is that church. It just means that at the moment it best fits.

    I'm not a bigot either for being upset with the church for going along with Constantine's order, that anyone who claimed to be Christian, yet didn't observe Sunday's holy day, Easter, and observed the Jewish festivals... was put to death. I follow the beliefs of those people, those people who had to live underground and flee the Roman empire.

    But due to studying, I have at least understood the Crusades more. After jumping off of the "Hate all Catholics train", I realized the Catholic church's point of view. I know that they screwed up big time, but that they had every reason to go into the holy land.

    Everyone is victim to bigotry. Atheists, all Christians, all Jews, all Muslims, etc. are victims of bigotry and lies. It's just a bad characteristic of mankind. I hope that we can all just get along in harmony like our father intended.

    If anyone really has any issues, they can always email me.

  • 1 decade ago

    It has been thus so since the time of Henry VIII.

    People have forgotten that Catholicism was outlawed in Britain until right up until the late 19th century. Catholics were discriminated against, killed and tortured by the protestant establishment. Priests had to hide in 'priest holes', monasteries were demolished, Catholic land and property was stolen, magnificent architecture and priceless art was deliberately destroyed etc. etc. Protestant thugs from Oliver Cromwell onwards went on the violent rampage in Ireland, killing and looting etc. (no wonder there has been unrest in that country ever since).

    The bigotry and discrimnation still exists in Britain's laws which continue to ban the Monarch from ever becoming or even marrying a Catholic.

    And would you credit that the people that committed these crimes against humanity claimed to be Bible believing, God fearing Christians? Just as their successors, the present day bigots claim.

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    I am Roman Catholic. I have been so demoralized with all the information about the priest that I have thrown my hands up. I was molested as a child (2 uncles). I adore the Catholic Mass but that is where I stop the association. I do not fellowship nor am I interested in the what the Vatican has to say about anything. I have a different take and it's a grudge against men period. They can not be trusted end of story. They can be trusted only when it is obvious that are not up to no good. I have no problem with this. I think you were eloquent and through in your post. I am fascinated with the propose of mass however I am haunted by the ugly events all through history that the Church has participated in.

  • 1 decade ago

    In all fairness, most of the hatred and bigotry come from fundamentalists who tend to think in terms of black and white, right and wrong, good and evil. Fundamentalism attracts that particular kind of individual -- one who can't accept the fact that different isn't wrong or evil.

    Catholicism is the perfect outlet for their paranoia ("Whore of Babylon," "the Pope will be the Anti-Christ") and fear of the 'outsider.' Mainstream branches of Protestantism are apparently reluctant to take another Protestant to task over their bigotry, so it's allowed to flourish unchecked.

    In fact, we see that all the time here in R&S. Catholics are defended by atheists, pagans, and other non-Christian people more often than they are by their own so-called 'fellow' Methodist or Presbyterian Christians. Sometimes I think they don't step out to support Catholics because they don't want to examine their own roots and rethink some of their own beliefs.

    Yet another case of "When the good remain silent, evil flourishes."

    Source(s): Catholic convert
  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    @ Vincent K, Atheati Mad Scientist

    ----You mention pedophiles in the Catholic Church as if it were more prominent than in Protestant Churches. If you did your homework, you would find that there are more cases levied against Protestant churches than the Catholic Church. People just like to focus on the Catholic Church because we are the largest Christian Church out there. Believe me, there is a reason why we have only 1 Catholic Church and Protestants have over 30k denominations...

    @ PartyMarty - "This is because of the lies they have taught over the centuries about the Creator of the universe."

    ----What lies are we spreading? That there is the Trinity? That Jesus, son of GOD came down and died for us, so that the gates of heaven will be reopened? Or that God will come again, to judge the living and the dead? Not sure what is wrong about this...

  • 6 years ago

    Bigotry accepted as long as their are lazy people who don't research Catholicism

    from a catholic, not protestant publication. Bigotry accepted while there liars and

    people who believe their lies. Bigotry accepted as long as their are stupid people.

    Bigotry accepted as long as catholics just take anti-Catholic garbage put to them.

  • 1 decade ago

    I totally understand how you feel. The only conclusion I can come to is that society just has it out for the Catholic Church!! but I don't know why! I mean every priest that turns out to be a child molester in on the news, yet there are child molesters that turn up in every religion, yet Catholics are always the ones getting cr@p for it.

    Also what annoys me is how when I make the sign of the cross in public, people look at me like im nuts!! but, people never look at Muslims weird, who wear the long dresses (forgot what they are called) and the turbin. I mean I don't want them too and thats good that they respect, but what about Catholics!! A nun once told me that when she went to Europe, young people would smirk at her and make comments when they would see her! That is sooo mean and disrespectful!!

    Catholicism is very moral and charitable religion, yet I just don't understand why people hate it!!

  • 1 decade ago

    Actually, America is more accepting of Catholicism in our times than in the past.

    Look at our hardship from the very beginning...We've come along way.

    Remember America's Protestant foundation...Witch hunt and the KKK are not that far behind us.

    Apparently, Protestants haven't changed that much...thank goodness the Laws have.

    God Bless

  • 1 decade ago

    I haven't seen bigotry towards Catholics in these discussions, but yes, there is criticism on their practices. I personally am an ex-cathloic. I would not say that they are Whores of babylon or Anti Christ. But I have to wonder if Catholics ever really considered why most of their own fellow Christians are critical of their practices. Catholics put up this wall of defense when they are criticized instead of asking questions about their own practices and seeing if its in line with the scriptures. Most catholics just accept what ever doctrines the Catholic church puts out there instead of researching to see if it lines up with the bible. But then again, the bible is not the only teaching that Catholics accept, which is a problem for other Christians outside of that institution. Catholics parade around like the ONLY church on the face of this earth YET, they are least likely to follow the scriptures WHOLEHEARTEDLY.

    I am not trying to be hostile here, just honest.

    Peace!

    Source(s): I never said bigotry was ok. Please read my sentences clearly before you respond. Nobody asked you to apologized about being Catholic. This is exactly what I am talking about...this defense. Criticism and bigotry are two different things, but you seem to be mixing them up.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Bigotry shouldn't be acceptable in any form. However, there is plenty to criticize the Catholic church about and I would like to point out that comparing the Catholic church to the Civil Rights movement is not at all valid.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.