Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

mattattack1984 asked in PetsDogs · 1 decade ago

what type of dog breed is best for me ?

I need some help picking a dog breed.

i will be a first time dog owner, even though i have never owned a dog before I do feel i will be able to properly train and discipline a dog. Im the type of person who knows how to prepare for something new. i have a great ability to learn from reading books and plan on buying several of them on how to train dogs, i also plan on watching several of cesar millan's dvd's.

im 25 years old, live in a single family house in lynn ma, a semi cold city environment with wide fluctuations in temperature average january temperature is probably around 30 degrees and maybe 85 degrees in july. Massachusetts is definitely on the colder side of the climate spectrum.

im a pretty active person, much more so in the summer than the winter. I enjoy long daily 10 - 20 mile bike trips, jogging, going for walks, would love to play Frisbee or fetch with a dog, im sure the dog could run along side my bike while im riding. i also wouldn't mind having a dog to pull me around on skis. (that seems really fun)

although im much less active in the colder months which is about half the year up here in the boston area, i would be up for bike rides and jogs even in the winter if my dog wants to go with me, (except on those absolutely frigid days, or bad weather conditions).

im also the lovey dubby type and would like a dog to show me affection, i would also enjoy rough housing with it on the occasion as well

what type of dog am i considering ?

before i go any further i must say I want a medium to large dog, for some reason i never liked small dogs and could never see myself owning one so that eliminates a lot of breeds right there.

im not expecting to get every thing i want, but would like a good mix of the attributes listed below.

1) be prone to as few health problems as possible. I know many breeds are prone to certain illness i would prefer a breed that is prone to relatively few illnesses

2) i want an affectionate dog, one that will give me kisses and hugs when i walk in the door, and will want to hang out with me and do stuff together, but then again i don't want one that will tear up the furniture when i leave for work, i will probably have to crate him / her

3) i want a dog with some guard dog instincts, im not looking for a dog that will attack anything that walks through the door, but one that will alert me of a stranger on my property, and will be willing to defend the property if necessary

4) i want a smart dog that has the ability to be trained, i plan on reading many books on how to train dogs so i should have an idea of how to do it. i would like them to be able to learn simple commands like sit, lay down, heel, relatively easily

5) the dog doesn't have to be friendly toward other pets but it's a plus

6) grooming, id prefer a dog that doesn't get hair all over the place, but eh what can you do, i don't have a problem grooming the dog just as long as it's no more than say 3 times a week.

7) i hate sitting around doing nothing all day and so should my dog, only problem is i work full time and will have to crate the dog while at work, i can let him out at lunch maybe take him for a quick walk, but then it's back in the crate until im home for the day, at that point i should be able to give plenty of exercise, except for those extremely cold days (say 25 degrees or less) or on bad weather days (although i will sometimes take them out on bad weather)

8) i want a dog that looks good to me, the particular breeds that have caught my eye are the Dalmatian, and Alaskan Husky

the particular breeds i've been focusing on include

german shepherd

dalmatian

alaskan husky

doberman

greyhound

(if you have in mind a better breed for me please mention it)

German Shepherd

PRO'S -

smart,

great ability to learn,

brave,

willing to protect the house,

likes to exercise,

and are affectionate

would be a great jogging / bike riding companion

CON's - must be properly trained in obedience or else can become very aggressive (i plan on properly training my dog but i would be a first time dog owner so it might not work out as expected)

the breed supposedly has all kinds of health problems

Dalmatian

PRO's

i think a Dalmatian would make a great long distance biking partner, it should also like to jog with me, play frisbee, fetch, tug of war and all the other fun stuff.

they are good companions

can be used as a guard dog

although they do have health issues, they seem to be less of an issue than in most other dogs, i imagine deafness won't be a problem because any puppy im considering, can be baer tested, they can get skin allergies, and can get urinary stones but those are all the major health issues i know of in this breed

they are beautiful animals, i love the way they look

CON's

i've heard they are difficult to train

they are hyperactive, although for the most part i think i can give him plenty of exercise i do think that hype

13 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I'd cross the greyhound off your list. I have one, love the breed, but don't think it would fit your lifestyle. These are dogs that are perfectly happy with 20 minute walks and 5-minute bursts of speed. Keep in mind that when they race, they are doing 30 to 40 seconds of running every 3 days or so. So definitely sprinters, not endurance runners. I have a feeling that the very thing that I and so many people love about the breed, their calm, peaceful, laid-back nature, would be very frustrating for you.

    Plus they make lousy guard dogs.

  • 1 decade ago

    Two breeds you might consider are Rotts and Flat Coated Retrievers. Both are extremely affectionate. I had a Flat that did field work and conformation. It's a pretty healthy breed because the breeders are very careful about thier lines. You won't ever see them advertised for sale, so you will have to find a breeder, or contact the rescue.

    Rotts don't complete thier physical or mental growth util they are three, so running with a bike too soon can damage growth plates. If bought from a reputable breeder they are pretty healthy. Men seem to do better with females, and male Rotts tend to be closer to women. I have 7 of them. My youngest girl Star is doing agility and obedience. They are great in colder temps because they are double coated. Again, there are a lot in rescues if you don't want a pup.

    Both rescues screen thier dogs and make sure there are no issues before they're adopted out.

    Source(s): Previous owner of FCR, German Shepherd, and have breed/owned Rotts for 13 years. I'm a professional dog trainer that specializes in hard cases. I stopped breeding 4yrs ago and now rescue Rotts.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I have to laugh because I think the perfect dog for you is a pitt bull. They are loyal, love able, cuddlers that love to play, can be trained without much trouble and are very active and would love all the outdoor attention you can offer it. I know so many people have there misconceptions about the breed but you sound like a very open minded individual that doesn't mind some research. I think you should google the breed and see what you think after reading up on the breed. I know everyone (myself included) says the best thing to do is rescue but i'm going to be a hypocrite this time and recommend finding a breeder or adopting a pit as a puppy. They are also a very healthy breed. Good luck to you, and just a warning.... Shepard's are finicky and take tons of activity and training every day. My friend jogs hers on a daily basis, when she was sick and missed about 4 days of it he was miserable. She actually asked me to take him because she couldn't stand it anymore. When I got back with him he was his old self again lol.

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    Irish Water Spaniel Soft Coated Wheaten Terrier Greyhound Giant Schnauzer Tibetan Terrier Poodle Portuguese Water Dog Wire haired Pointing Griffon Basenji

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    I see that you had done your homework... You have a pretty good idea of what you want. I would suggest:

    Siberian Husky or Malamute, due to the cold weather.

    Dalmatians are not known for being smart. Cute? yes, but not that easy to train.

    Border Collies are one of the smartest dogs. They are not that big, but definitely not small either. Agile, intelligent, always trying to please their humans, and cute too. They are not an aggressive breed.

    German Shepherds are beautiful but some of them are huge and if not very well trained, they can be aggressive toward other dogs or people, if they think you are being attacked. Also, if not from a reputable breeder, they are prone to hip dysplasia.

    good luck in your search for the perfect canine companion!

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Although normally, I would never suggest this breed of dog for first time dog owners, I would bring up the Australian Cattle Dog. They are very active and energetic dogs and need a strong owner with a strong enough personality to match their own. They need lots of exercise and can usually keep going long after you are worn out. They have two layers of fur to guard them from the weather. They can be extremely affectionate and loving but they are known as Velcro or shadow dogs. They literally stick to you and you only. They are wary around strangers but as long as they are socialized as pups they will become accepting to all people, just don't expect them to be everyone's best friend. They are a herding breed so they do have a tendency to nip, just work on training them. They are medium sized breed with enough stamina to work from dawm until dusk in the Australian outback. And relatively speaking are a fairly new breed and have a lot of influence including the Dingo and dalmatian, so generally speaking are not prone to many diseases. They shed their coat twice a year and its a fairly fast process since it tends to come off in clumps. And finally, because they are a one person dog, they will follow you to the ends of the earth and are easy to train as long as you have the more dominant personality. Ceaser Milan's training techniques work really well on this breed and overall. They aren't the best for city environments but that's because they usually don't get near enough exercise. But if you are constantly on the go, then it would work.

    Otherwise, many of the breeds you picked out are of a slightly more difficult level to train and are all primarily of highly driven breeds which can easily become very aggressive unless trained properly. German shepards, Dobermans and Dalmations are all on the top 10 most aggressive dog list. Huskies are also known for their aggressive tendencies if not trained correctly. But as long as they are well socialized, VERY WELL... they will all be fine, it's all in how you train them.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I would go with either a Greyhound, Border Collie, Siberian Husky, or Labrador Retriever.

    Greyhounds- Athletic, smart, brave, great stamina (for long bike rides), very gentle, very sweet, pretty protective

    Border Collie- Agile, athletic, good with kids, intelligent, gentle

    Siberian Husky- Strong (if you wanted to do the ski thing or dog sledding), smart, independent, very good watch/guard dog, great family dog, very kind

    Labrador- Athletic, strong, sturdily-built, very, very, very sweet and gentle.

    All are pretty easy-going and easy to housebreak as puppies. But honestly, go with a shelter/pound dog. Every time you buy a dog from a purebred dog breeder, guess who pays the price? So many are put down! My first three dogs were all mutts and they were my favorites!

  • 1 decade ago

    How about a Boston Terrier? They are medium sized and have a smooth coat. They love to give kisses and are very playful. They have french bulldog in them so they will make an okay guard dog.

    You could always go to any shelter like the Boston Animal Rescue League. Play with all of the dogs and puppys and see what one is fit for you.

  • 1 decade ago

    Adopt a dog from any local shelter, they really need a home because most are put down(die) due to over crowding and not enough funds to care for.

    You go there, look among the dogs they are and choose the best one using your judgment.

    You know once they start giving you those puppy eyes you won't be walking out with out one :D

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    You might want to consider adopting a dog from a shelter house. Check this out.

    http://lnk.nu/dogtime.com/ryh

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.