Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Maureen asked in Pregnancy & ParentingParenting · 1 decade ago

Why do children bully & harass other children?

And, besides punishing them, what might be done to teach them/give them the self-respect, personal pride and sense of responsibility for themselves that might help turn their lives around?

I'm thinking about those teens in the Phoebe Prince case whose parents, apparently, did not teach them how to treat other people when they were younger. Could something have been done by other well-meaning adults in their lives, during their younger school years, that may have taught them what their parents didn't?

And, I'm thinking about my own children & their classmates in elementary school. I'm active in the school & know that some of those kids come from homes where they don't get the attention & parenting that they need. I try to mentor those kids when I'm there. And, I tried to model & teach responsibilty & empathy in my Cub Scout Pack, when I was cubmaster.

But, I'm wondering if there might be some other programs or approaches that you've seen put to use, successfully, in your own schools & communities. I'd like to bring some ideas to the next PTO and Council meetings.

I agree that harassing and threatening behavior should be punished. The kids who do that should know that there are consequences for their behavior. But, if they keep doing the thing that they are punished for, then it's clear to me that they don't know how or why to stop doing it (besides just to avoid punishment). There's something missing in their basic understanding of decent human behavior. And, there's something missing in their sense of pride in themselves & their choices. I'd like to help find answers that will work for those kids who are on the wrong path.

Update:

I think, too, that some of the reason for bullying is that kids give in to peer pressure & that it escalates as more voices join in. So, a kid who might not do it otherwise, loses him/herself in the mob. So, I'd also like to brainstorm ways to address that in a school situation - really address it, really get kids to think about it & to have the strength to recognize that behavior is wrong, even if 'everyone else is doing it & seemingly having fun doing it'.

4 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Monkey see, monkey do.

    Kids who are treated with unkindness and casual cruelty (emotionally or physically) by their parents usually turn around and do the same to someone else the moment they find a weakness and opportunity, or they become the victim to other children as well as adults.

    If you had your feelings and body casually disregarded by someone, what would stop you from doing the same thing to someone else?

    I don't think punishment works. Punishment makes people more motivated to lie, conceal their activities, distrust adults and shuts down communication, which is what they really need. It doesn't change what caused them to want to mistreat another person in the first place; if anything, it gives them even more motivation to do so. Punishment MAKES kids lie and be sneaky, it teaches them nothing except that they have to be smarter about doing the wrong thing the next time. Punishment doesn't educate, it doesn't change minds, it doesn't rehabilitate. It doesn't even usually modify behaviour, unless of course you count the fear of being caught driving better deception tactics. Some people do just need to be punished: sociopathic serial killers, drug lords, deluded religious fanatics. But most kids, most people, can be rehabilitated and our society seems to have a real problem with the difference between punishment and rehabilitation. Punishment is a revenge. Rehabilitation is teaching why something is wrong and showing a person how to do the right thing instead.

    If adults are tired of seeing kids and teens bully, harass, and show unkindness not only to each other but back at adults, perhaps they need to stop modelling that behaviour to their children. It never fails to shock me when I see some lady (and it is usually a lady) smack her kid while saying, "YOU DON'T HIT!" or even better, yelling, "WE DON'T YELL." Where do you think the kid learned it?!

    If society wants to start changing how kids interact with each other, we need to not only change how we interact with them, but how we interact with each other as adults.

    I honestly don't think any amount of after school programs, Very Special Episodes of tv shows, token lectures at school or phoney "teaching sessions" is going to teach compassion, empathy, understanding, tolerance or good behaviour. Compassion and decent behaviour isn't learned because a cub scout leader or a teacher does a little talk and makes a kid go through some meaningless exercise. It comes from first being treated with compassion and having examples of compassion, and from an internal will to do good that is developed through genuine (IE not forced or arranged/structured) experience with other people of all ages and kinds - something today's overscheduled, overdirected kids wholly lack - and through guidance.

    Again, guidance and dictation being two very different things that our society does not differentiate as much as it needs to. Dictation says, "do this and this because I tell you to, because you don't have a choice, and because there will be punishment if you don't." Guidance says, "I think this is the right choice, here's why it's the right choice, and here's why you should WANT to make the right choice even though you have the option to make the wrong one and the wrong one might be easier or more immediately satisfying."

    Kids need a lot less dictation, and a lot more guidance. Guidance is work. Dictation and punishment is easy. When we get to that point of doing what's right rather than what's easy, I think empathy and a better way of interacting with each other and the world will follow for ALL of us, not just children.

    (But I'm not holding my breath.)

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    i think its human nature to be cruel. we have such potential for empathy and kindness but when it comes down to it every man has a heart of darkness, it's our everlasting struggle to fight those inner demons. Being cruel to someone is a very primal and bestial act that was probably better served in the early ages of man when competition for resources mean ones very survival. it reminds me of raising a puppy, as we all know that puppy has the potential to be a great dog if shown love compassion and a firm hand in its youth. sadly a lot of kids dont get this and its akin to that old adage: "you cant teach an old dog new tricks"

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    its evolution, same reason one baby bird will peck the weaker baby bird to death in the nest

    half are instinctual wild animals who base their belief system on Darwinism

    half are intellectually superior humans who base their belief system on humanity

    basically people do it because instinct drives them and they literally CANNOT stop themselves, all tracing back to the root emotion of FEAR

    the question becomes how to distinguish between good humanity and bad humanity, which can mimic each other if not carefully examined.

  • 1 decade ago

    kids want attention and girls especially love drama i attend an all girls high school and the ridicule is horrible. eventually they will grow out of this stage.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.