Is this creationists logic?

If humans are made of ashes, then trees are made of chairs.

Yep

Actually when you burn a body, the carbon all becomes a gas, not dirt. Only a creationist wouldn't know that.

If the only way we can be turned to dust is through the forced combustion of our chemical makeup, then it's not very logical to say we are made of dust. It's like saying we're made out of noxious fumes.

it truly is sweet judgment defined by an anti-creationist. i have self belief God is the author of the universe; yet, does that make me a Creationist? i do not consider the perception that the universe and the earth is 6,000 yrs old. it truly is an theory in conserving with assumption.( filling in gaps )

Merriam-Webster's first definition for dirt is "excrement", which seems appropriate here.

I think that may have been initially misunderstood. The creationist logic is excrement... meh. It's just not funny when you have to explain it. ;)

@Christopher: Just because you would "rather" things be the way you imagine, that does not make it true.

Cremation creates ash .not dirt (soil)

Dirt is simply undefined debris

But aren't apes also dirt ? ;-)

Or is it that both of these god's-beautiful-creatures excrete dirt? :-P

no its not what you claim are bodies return back to the dust and dirt we were taken from

every hear of ashes to ashes dust to dust

I rather come from dirt than apes.