Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

This question is for people who think they know more about Transsexualism than those of us who suffer from it?

What qualifies you to dismiss this condition as a mental disorder, a delusion, or something similar? I'm not asking you what your beliefs about Transsexualism are, I'm asking you why YOU specifically, a non-transsexual, think you are qualified to comment on a condition that NOBODY other than another Transsexual person can truly understand.

Even if you were, say, a gender therapist who worked with hundreds of Transsexual people, or a scholar who devoted themselves to the study of this phenomenon, or a medical researcher who did actual lab work to try and understand the cause, would that allow you to FEEL what we feel?

Would any of that allow you to experience the anxiety of being a child trying to suppress your natural behaviors and mannerisms, while trying in vain to acquire those of the gender you're told you are?

Would it help you to understand why everyone told you it was wrong for you to want the pink magic marker, or the sneakers with rainbows on them, or the red bicycle instead of the blue one?

Would it give you any insight into what it felt like to sit in a barber chair with tears streaming down your cheeks as you watched locks of your long hair fall to the ground, not understanding why your parents insisted you look like a handsome young man.

Would it allow you to understand what it feels like to have 3rd grade boys gang up on you and call you names like "fa**ot, or homo, and make fun of how you throw, or run, or cry - because you don't understand why people hate you simply for "being."

Would it help you to know what it feels like to cry yourself to sleep night after night because your voice was starting to get deep, and there was nothing you could do to stop it?

Would it help you to experience the disgust of watching hair begin growing all over your body, and worse, on your face, and then feel the embarrassment and shame of having to use a razor to shave it off.

Would it help you to experience the pain of disappointing your mother by never getting a graduation photo, or yearbook photo for her to treasure, simply because you couldn't stand the idea of her thinking of you as her boy becoming a man.

Would it help you to understand why a group of seniors would carjack you and repeatedly smash your skull into the sidewalk because they were convinced that someone who never dated a girl had to be gay - even though you knew you weren't gay.

Would it allow you to feel the awkwardness of trying to establish some sort of relationship with a woman just so other people wouldn't wonder why you're 26 and never had a girlfriend or sex because you couldn't stand the sight of your own body, or the thought of showing it to someone else.

Would it give you even the slightest inkling of what it feels like to stare at a piece of paper thinking about how to say goodbye to your family because you could no longer take the feeling of being something you knew you weren't, and decided it would be better to just not live anymore?

Would it translate the absolute terror of telling another person something so shameful that you kept inside yourself for over 40 years?

Would it allow you to experience the sickening prospect of losing EVERYTHING you know and love, your spouse, children, family, friends, career, home, possessions, just to take a shot at trying to get back some semblance of a livable life, knowing that there is no guarantee you will even make it?

Will it let you feel the sadness and pain of grown adults insulting you, spitting on you, protesting you, teaching their children to hate you, seeing groups of teens break into peels of laughter as you pass, or store clerks giggle after you make a purchase, or your boss lie to you face and tell you he's letting you go because business is slow?

You think you know us. You think you know about our condition... about our lives... about our despair... about our losses... about our motives... about our sanity... when the truth is you don't know S-H-I-T! You know less than nothing. You are vincibly ignorant.

The one thing you do know is your childish, disgusting hate, and the temporary pleasure you get from insulting and invalidating people who've never done you an ounce of harm - people who want nothing more than to be treated like ordinary human beings. People who are not even asking you to understand, but just to be civil.

To John (Jeune, Pete C, whoever the hell you are), A Yahoo, snotalie, Tara J, and the handful of others who come to LGBT on a daily basis to spew hatred, my question to you is this... What is it in your twisted, angry minds that compels you to take precious minutes of your life to be mean to other human beings who haven't done a damn thing to you?

You don't even have to answer me. Just answer yourselves, honestly, and then REALLY think to yourselves... "do I know ANYTHING about Transsexual people, and why do I need t

Update:

@ John - thank you for answering this question. I wanted to demonstrate to everyone that you are totally enslaved by your obsession, and you couldn't ignore transpeople if you tried

It's obvious why you are unable to explain to us what qualifies you to comment on Transsexualism, because you really don't know, do you?

The joke, you see, is on you.

While all these examples true, and while most Transpeople can relate to at least a few of them on some level, we need neither pity nor sympathy from the likes of you. What gratifies me (and others I hope) is watching you, helpless, like a puppet on a string, do exactly what I want. Do you think I don't know what sort of stuff you'd respond to? Do you think I don't know EXACTLY the sort of question that would bring out the worst in you. I pull the strings and you react, and all your impotent efforts to deride me and invalidate Transsexualism, can never change the fact that you are a weak, pathetic man who dances at my command.

17 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I read every word of your post and I completely agree with you. I have seen my sister go through the exact same things over & over & over. From the second she decided to come out with her feelings when she was much younger until now. She is 50. She is beautiful. Intelligent beyond her years. Funny. Honest. Caring. Lovable. And even forgiving of those who have trashed her home several times & stolen anything they can get their hands on just because she is transgender. She has been brutally attacked several times just because she is transgender. Her life has been a living hell just because she chose to live the truth & not some lie. She has lost her parents,her friends,jobs,and more than I can mention.

    I don't claim to know more about it than a transgender,but I thank God my sister has talked to me & helped me understand it. I am 100% in favor of her decision to transform physically into the person she was born to be. I love her with all my heart & respect her more than any other individual on the planet.

    Transexuality is about being who you really are. And it horrifies me that some ignorant jack@sses can't accept another human being for having the guts to be honest about their sexuality. But like gays & lesbians & sometimes even bis...we are all persecuted by what I like to call judgemental fundies.

    Peace & love to ALL transgenders,gays,lesbians & bisexuals. Be true to yourself & to hell with those who can't accept you for who you were born to be.

    Source(s): Lesbian & not ashamed of it! Sister of transexual M2F (You ROCK sis!!!)
  • 1 decade ago

    Maybe I'm wrong here, but I don't see trans people as being much different from anyone else. Yes, things CAN be more difficult for them, but they aren't always. Trans people are not always suffering. They're like anyone else. We all have insecurities. We all have stress & anxiety. We may all suffer a bit at one point or another. We all struggle. Everyone should try to find good in a situation & do what they can to feel better about themselves. Whether you're gay, straight, trans, bi, or somewhere in between doesn't really matter. We're all people. I'm sure things are different for everyone, but I believe we can all find ways to understand how others feel, at least a little.

    It seems to me that you're angry with people who try to tell you that it's stupid to want gender reassignment surgery, or hormones when you were born with that body. I'd be angry too. Please don't be angry with those of us who try to understand. I see no problem with trying to understand how others feel. I believe it helps us all get along a bit better.

    Source(s): Me, my best friend who's a post-op F2M man
  • Religious intolerance is used to justify institutionalized ignorant counterproductive attitudes towards people through no fault of their own, have a predetermined genetic predisposition that medical science has yet to fully investigate it's consistent genetic pattern of prescience.

    Evolution in humans is still not fully understood and you have every right to be furious at those who second guess through religiously correct ignorance, what you are & how you need to become that person your parents denied you from becoming in order for you to have what most of us take for granted, a normal sense of self and who we are not just to the world, but who we are to those people who love us unconditionally without any reservations.

    Please don't allow the lowest common denominator of hate-monger, anti-evolution religious ignoramuses to keep you from realizing what you need to be as a individual gender so that you can become that person you've been fighting against societal taboos and ignorant restrictions to become the gender you're most comfortable as.

    Strip away the hatred-centric ignorance of religious slavery and most people who are capable of supporting you want exactly what everybody wants.

    To be loved and to be accepted for what you are from the inside out, not what makes shallow people comfortable by forcing people to capitulate to a cookie-cutter version of what human genders are "supposed to be".

    Source(s): Juxtaposition
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    well in psychology they teach that transexuality is a disease but they also teach that numerous studies prove that people are born gay but it doesn't make sense since similar things cause both. so i think you're born transsexual your brain is more similar to the opposite genders but you just happen to have the wrong body. of course some people accept it it's similar to when someone doesn't accept their body for other reasons transsexuals don't accept it because of the wrong genitals but a lot of people learn to accept themselves without surgery.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    I think it far more important that people become tolerant of transsexuality than argue about the suffixes.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Hey Erica

    Unfortunately i think that question will be wasted because people aren't going to read it. People are selfish in general and don't care about something unless it directly effects them or applies to them in some form.

    For the people who feel they need to hate transsexuals and come here dishing out more hate and phobia, they're just plain limited people. They're unable to empathise or see anything beyond themselves. That if it doesn't make sense to them then it therefore must be wrong and that's really my point, those kind of people aren't worth crap. They're just unintelligent with a narrow scope of the world we live in.

    I don't mind if people misunderstand us, i don't expect people to automatically get it, but people should at least realise they don't have the right to make comments or conclusions based on ignorance. If you aren't a transsexual then you don't know how this feels and therefore you need to shut up unless you have something constructive to say.

    I think that ultimately people should just stay out of our business.

    Source(s): transguy
  • 1 decade ago

    Well, apparently, those people you're directing this towards are not here right now.

    But I have a question for you--why would you do all this ranting about people who think transsexualism is a mental disorder/delusion after you phrase it as something you "suffer" from? If you mean "suffer" as in emotionally, I can get it. Even still, I wouldn't have said "suffer"...because you are who you are. Everyone has tough experiences, many of us based on some aspect of who we are (you're in the LGBT section...riddled with lesbians and gays and bisexuals, yes, but they all "suffer" because of who they are). Still, you're trans and you can't change it, and it just makes it sound like you're not happy with yourself because you're trans if you mean "suffer" that way. But my first thought was...actually, it comes off as "suffer" as in a mental condition or a medical illness.

    But don't mind me...since I'm not trans, I couldn't possibly know ANYTHING about the issue...(sarcasm).

  • ?
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Erica, once again a deep and insightful question (and one that brought tears to my eyes).

    It's such a shame that the people who would most benefit from considering it are the ones who won't bother reading it, or will dismiss it.

    It's worth a star, anyway, so here's one.

  • 1 decade ago

    Thank you Erica.

    John,,All I can say to you is go perform an unnatural sex act with yourself.

  • 1 decade ago

    I don't think anybody could understand how it feels but if it helps i support anyone in being who they are

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.