Can I use 2 different moisturizers on different parts of my face?

I've started using an oil-based moisturizer on my face, to try to clear up the excess oil I've been getting on my forehead, due to my fringe now covering it (I'm using an oil-based product because I read in a magazine that you should fight "fire with fire", or oil with oil in this case).

It seems to be working, my forehead is much less problematic. However, since I've started using this product, the rest of my face has become extremely dry (to the point of mild flaking).

So basically I was wondering if using my oil-based product on just my forehead, and a different one to counter my dry cheeks and chin, would balance out my whole face?

Oh and product suggestions would be helpful. :)