Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Why all religions come in very few years ago?

Well, I knew that many religions like Hinduism were come around 5000 years ago. And b4 2500-3000 years ago Abrahamic religions were (Jew/ Christian/ Islam) come….

But as per human civilization, humans made remarkable progress before this religions comes…humans were already made towns, nations, ethic groups, languages, farming, and military fighting politics,cultures n made own Gods. If you doubt that than read history and watch proofs of Harappa civilizations, even b4 dholavira civilization in west India, native American ethic groups civilizations, early Europeans Chinese civilization, early Egyptian civilization..

Read history how human start farming, start to living in society, and biggest contributions are to make many languages, make great examples of engineering..

So

1.where is our god at that time? Why god not sent his messengers or prophets or come him self?

2.What happen with those souls who born b4 this religions born?

All were gone to hell?

3.Why all Ancient people’s religious believes (as per archaeological proofs they believe in some or some deities) was wrong? And we are right? How we decide it?

4.What was god doing in ancient time?

5.how can we sure that today’s god/messengers will still acceptable in future? May be they have new one?

I asked question because of curiosity, not to heart any sentiments. But I want to know with every civilization change why there superpower (god) also change? After all, god never change!@@#

12 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    "humans made remarkable progress before this religions comes…humans were already made towns, nations, ethic groups, languages, farming, and military fighting politics,cultures n made own Gods. "

    Why does humanity and agriculture have to be synonymous with religion? Religion didn't cause the existence of humans. I don't think anyone doubts that man existed before organized religion did. Man always needs to search for something, some reason for being here...thus organized religion was born. And yes, you will have different religions spawned every few generations or so. (Look at mormonism and scientology...just a few that are relatively new). But, in response to your question regarding the existence of god/gods before recording of religion, I don't believe all people "born before religion" as you put it go to hell. I don't believe in hell. But, religiously speaking, that would be a good question to ask....If god came to save humanity from itself and give the option of heaven...where did the people who died before he "came to save" go? Again, one more reason I choose not to believe in a fictitious deity.

  • 1 decade ago

    You have answered yourself "as per archaeological proofs they believe in some or some deities"

    Till date the same is going on and will continue so in future as well. You have raised this question because you believe the religion you are following is true and rest are false. When you date back your religion and ask where was my God before this. Whereas humans had been believing in divinity in some form or the other from the known history. God was there in ancient times, he is here now and will remain here in future. Only the religion, the way of worshiping and set of beliefs will change.

  • DS
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    Religion was a way for the extremely ignorant to make sense with how the world works. Then is was used as a scare tactic to control the masses with fear .They were the first Democrats. Since then education has been slowly fixing the problem but there will be forever the lazy and weak who use religion as an excuse and a crutch. It will be very hard to make lazy people stop taking the easy way out.

    There is no magic in the sky its just us down here screwing up what we have with crazy superstitions and cults

  • 1 decade ago

    NICE QUESTION DUDE.

    first of all, please correct yourself.

    hinduism originated about 10,000 years ago. Rigveda was written in beggining of 8000 BC. Other vedas were written after that. Ramayana written in 6000 BC and Mahabharata around 3500 BC.

    Abrahamic religions did not come on same day.

    Jewis originated 3000 years ago.

    Christianity originated 2500 years ago.

    Islam originated 6000 years ago.

    Well, here is what I percieve.

    Ans 1: GOD is never changed. No religion mentions that they create GOD. Infact messengers are sent to show the right way not the right religion. GOD is there even if he is not discovered by religion makers. We have air but we can't see it. That's the only difference - GOD is always invisible. This GOD is discovered by someone not invented. Regarding sending of messengers and civilizations, most of the world was nomadic. Those civilizations which you are speaking was based on ancient religions. e.g. Harappa and MohanJodaro were explained well in Mahabharata. GOD can not come himself so sends messengers but most of them quit to change people and some manage to do it. They never say that they are superior. It is wrongly percieved only.

    Ans 2: Nothing happens with them. Why would they go to hell? No GOD mentions - my disbelievers go to hell. Today, real original scriptures are destroyed. People get fake scriptures and develop mis conceptions. Only they who were sinners will go to hell. Believing no GOD is not a sin.

    Ans 3: Who told you this? Their proofs aren't wrong always. Basically, myth spreads faster than truth. They would have done right surveys and discovered right GOD - remember truth is same but is interpret in different manners. If today, it is found wrong then we are wrong.

    Ans 4: Absolutely nothing. GOD never worries like you and me - what will happen next? Well GOD is so impartial that he says - believe in only truth but doesnot mention what truth. In those times, GOD wasn't trying to come on earth. Infact, GOD never worried for that. GOD only sends messengers if the world is on a wrong path. Wrong path here doesnot means wrong religion - it only means misguidance and increased sin level.

    Ans 5: No comments here.

    Note: With civilization change GOD need not change, only perception is changed, interpretation method is changed. Today, we worship say GOD A, tomorrow B then we actually see A in the form of B or A within B.

    Source(s): ekam sadam vipraah bahudhaa vadanti (The holy Rigveda) MEANING: THE TRUTH IS SAME BUT IS ALWAYS INTERPRET DIFFERENTLY BY SAGES
  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    1. Before recorded history, we know little of what people did in regards to their dealing with God.

    Any notion that there was no form of worship is speculative. We don't know.

    2. I personally, doubt that prehistoric humans are all going to Hell. Sharing a slab of bison with a starving grandmother was a heroic gesture, even then.

    3. Good point ! We cannot decide if they were right or wrong.

    4. God, as always sustains creation throughout time. I believe God lives outside of time as we know it.

    5. New things can happen. Still, when God makes a covenant, You can rely on Him to keep it.

    Source(s): Jesus is Lord
  • 1 decade ago

    You ask a lot of very good questions, some of which mainstream churches would try to avoid. The laws of existence, of life have been from the beginning of time and shall always be. Man however likes to meddle. Out of which emerged society as we know it today with all its complications, sicknesses, heartaches, and yes... religions. Go figure! I hope this helps.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    The Early Church Fathers predicted that Christianity in general wouldn't mind the lack of a direct face to face contact with “God,” like Moses did, as long as they have access to an exclusive book about God. The Bible writers picture God to be so cruel that the idea of reading only the nicer stories about him is the best deal that any Christian can really bargain for!

    Even religions evolve...

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Very good reasons not to believe in the god.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Um, Abraham came from the city of Ur thousands of years before you claim in your post

    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    RE 2.What happen with those souls who born b4 this religions born? All were gone to hell?

    Religion can't save anyone, only God saves. Since God existed in ancient times, people could always be saved.

  • 1 decade ago

    Religion....don't know...

    But 'God' has existed from the birth of modern man.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.