Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

? asked in Arts & HumanitiesTheater & Acting · 1 decade ago

Comedic/dramatic monologue reviews?

Well, I've got an audition coming up. We don't know anything about the play, we're just required to have a one-minute comedic monologue. Linked are two videos where I perform a total of 5 monologues, two comedic in one and three dramatic in the other. Please read the information box on the videos BEFORE you comment. Those are the things I am looking for constructive criticism in and those only. Nothing about appearance, unless you're just suggesting overall auditioning appearance. This audition is more casual, but we are required to look somewhat nice. I cannot wear my more guyish/comfortable things, for example. Like cargo shorts. Anyway, just overall things like that are perhaps ok.

Thank you!

Comedic: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L5tCWDfopFw

Dramatic: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0EK9rJmLun0

I would like you to comment on the actual videos first, then place that response in here to answer it for points. However, if you do not have a YouTube account, on here alone is fine. Just make sure that it addresses what I asked.

Update:

I would like you to specifically talk about each of these things:

-Physical acting (how I'm working with my arms, hands, movement, posture, etc)

-Voice acting (literally, how my voice is helping the monologue)

-Chair usage (when applicable, how does the chair help or distract?)

-Overall fit (for me; explain how)

-Audition worthy-ness (would you accept this at an audition?)

Thank you! I love hearing that I've done well, but I would like specifics as to what I'm doing right and what you would want me to change.

Also, just post your username if you have commented on my video for the credit.

3 Answers

Relevance
  • Jess
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Comedic Monologue #1:

    I think you can do more with your body. It seemed like you were just swinging your arms in frustration, and maybe the script limited you. You need to vary your pitch. There were some lines that I thought "Oh, it would be so much funnier if spoken this way (inflection, emphasis, volume, etc.)" I can explain that over the phone some time. The choices you made with the chair were golden. ;) You only sat down and moved when appropriate, so I wasn't distracted by your movement at all. If the show is a comedy, you should definitely consider using this piece, but I recommend cutting some lines; even though it was only 2:22, I felt like it was longer. It dragged on a bit near the end, when I thought you were almost done, you weren't. If the play is a drama, don't use it.

    Comedic Monologue #2:

    Okay, it was funny when I read it, but now that I've seen you perform it, I don't think it's a good piece for you. It's not a monologue in which you, Maria, can let go of yourself and take huge risks. You were not as confident in this piece as you were in the other one, and of those two, I like your performance of the first one better. I can tell you that your slate needs some work. I couldn't understand your name (even though I know it), so just articulate more. Don't be defeated at the end. You may not feel like you did a mediocre job, but it showed on your face. Take that moment to slip into character in the beginning, and wait a beat when you are finished, otherwise the audience loses the moment. You looked as if you didn't know what to do with chair, and hopping over it when you say "Vote for me, don't vote for me, don't vote at all..." was *very* distracting.

    "VOTE for me, DON'T vote for me...don't vote AT ALL." Try that. :o)

    Dramatic Monologue #1:

    WOW!!! When you perform a dialect, you age like twenty years! I'm not sure how old the character is, but *you*, become so much more mature! This monologue suits you to a tee. I can tell that you were totally into it. So, it's like, after your slate, "Where did Maria go?" The only thing that I can equate that to is when I perform Fantine's monologue to Javert...you know what I said about that. That's what I see in this piece for you. :D This one is my favorite dramatic piece for your audition. The only suggestion I have is to explore your body more! You have a habit of just using your arms...well most actors do anyway, but there was too much pointing. There were lots of opportunities for you to get more physical, so sit down and read it again, to find those moments.

    Dramatic Monologue #2:

    You did a great job, but this piece was not as powerful as the first. Is it the same character? If not then you wouldn't be using the same dialect. Again, remember you've got a whole body to work with! I think at one point you dropped the dialect. You weren't talking like you normally do, but it was more of the standard stage voice. It happens sometimes, but that's when the energy drops and even if you can pick up the dialect again pretty soon, the speech drags, which it did

    Dramatic Monologue #3:

    I'm sorry, but I don't like the piece, or your delivery. The energy was DEAD. I'm guessing it was because it was the fifth monologue, and you were tired of speaking, I don't know. I couldn't understand hardly anything you said, because your volume was at a minimum, which I must say does not make it more dramatic, it just falls flat. Then your sentences and words just ran together like you wanted to get it over with. If that happens, that's a red flag. If you don't like performing the monologue, obviously, you will not put your whole heart into it and nothing happens. Rod Caspers told us that last year in the MT workshop, remember? That one girl's audition went really well because the auditioners could tell that she likes the song, which contributed to her successful performance. You sat down most of the time, which I thought was odd...unless your character is paralyzed or handicapped in any other way, the chair should not limit your movements, it should only help you! Then you stood up in it...you're right, not a good choice. I read the YouTube comment. You can do both comedy and drama. They are equally favoring you as an actress. Contemporaries are your thing, so I wouldn't brand you as either a comedienne or dramatic actress. You can do both if the play is contemporary. Do you realize that you and Caitlin told me the same thing? That I *am* funny, and I am *very* dramatic, when I am performing in a classical play. My picks: first comedic monologue, first dramatic monologue.

    Source(s): Your bestie from theatre camp.
  • ?
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    Dramatic And Comedic Monologues

  • 1 decade ago

    Your pretty good!

    Source(s): Instincts!
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.