Is this a good trade for me?

YES you need another elite WR to start and you get that with Marshall (whoever said hes downgrading at QB is retarted Henne is better then Orton) Eli consistently gives 24+ touchdowns and whooever said NY is a run first team is again has no clue what there talking about Jacobs and Bradshaw combined for 387 carries last year and Eli threw it 509 times and he has weapons.... and Mendenhall is a top 10 back and is projected over 200 points and you have depth with turner, Best, and Williams

I personally would take the trade. Brandon Marshall is an elite receiver while Pierre Garcon is only second string. Mendenhall is also a top 10 running back. I watched LeSean McCoy during the preseason games and he didn't impress me. Eli and his receivers will be good to go by the start of the season and with Brandon Jacobs slowing down, I expect Eli will be passing more this year and get at least 3500 yards.

With all do respect.

ARE U CRAZY???

Tom Brady is the man. Love the Eagles or hate them, McCoy is there only back, that means plenty of touches. Pierre will only be getting more and more throws.

All Eli's receivers are hurt, plus the Giants like to run the ball. Marshall's on a new team with Chad Henning. Rashard's good, but he's the only up side.

Take it. Manning is a dependable quaterback. Marshall and Mendenhall are no. 1 r unning backs. I think that Brady is past his prime now. Garcon is in a spread the ball offense right now and mccoy has been playing poorly in camp.

nah brady and garcon are good...marshall is playing with a new QB and a worse QB so his numbers wont reciprocate...manning shaky...mendenhall not huge upgrade from mccoy

Do NOT make that trade