Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Why do People think the United States Military is weak?
I hear this mostly from people who don't live within the USA. They say that we lost in Vietnam and that we are losing in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Well I say. **** YOU kindly. How about your country gets involved with a Guerrilla war! As far as I know, no foreign army has ever defeated a well-equipped and well-trained guerrilla army in the history of the world. So when you compare us to the UK, France, Russia, or even China you are seriously missing something.
We defeated England in the American Revolution and Later in the War of 1812. And even recently, The UK can even get a handle on the IRA even though they are so close to their home.
France got their **** kicked in WWII and later on in Vietnam. Need I say more?
The USSR failed to defeat the Mujaheddin in Afghanistan and then later just lost the overall cold war when their government collapsed and formed Russia.
The only thing China has is their insanely large population and their high production. They also failed to defeat India in 1962.
And another thing about Vietnam. Our military isn't the reason why we "lost" in Vietnam. In case you didn't know the USA inflicted 20X more casualties to them then they did to us. If you want to know why we lost you should look inside of America and blame the hippie liberals for forcing us out of Vietnam.
Now. For my fair and unbiased portion of my "question" I'll give a fair evaluation on how well America would do against other superpowers.
USA vs. Russia: This would be a huge war because these two countries are currently the top super powers of the world. I think that its pretty even and who ever is the country defending would win. More so for Russia because of their harsh terrain.
USA vs. China: I would say the same for this war. Neither Army would be able to defeat the other with out the home-field advantage. Bu USA's Navy and Air Force is clearly superior while China would be able to produce more (but less quality) war machines.
USA vs. UK: In honesty I would say that the USA would be able to pull through a long bloody war to a victory. But the Victory would only come at a high cost in life, equipment and munitions.
USA vs. France: Without any outside intervention, USA would win no contest. France has been conquered before it would be hard to do it again.
There it is. Please post your comments and "answers" to my "question"
how many for you actually read my post?
13 Answers
- ?Lv 51 decade agoFavorite Answer
I agree with what you're saying for the most part but you're missing several facts.
- The Patriots had A LOT of help in the Revolutionary War. France constantly helped the Patriots by giving them supplies, troops, and other aid. Spain was also aiding them. Then there was the Republic of Dutch and Netherlands. America by no means defeated the British alone.
- France is not weak. You're basing your theory on old stereotypes that the French are all incompetent cowards who will surrender after a single shot is fired. The French military is actually the second most powerful in Europe. Only slightly behind the UK. (Not counting Russia.)
- I don't believe Russia ever had a chance in Afghanistan... HOWEVER. The US provided the Mujahideen with many weapons and supplies. This undeniably helped the Mujahideen inflict much more damage on the Russian military.
Most foreigners who talk about Vietnam just don't really have a clue what they're talking about in the first place. Foreigners are under the impression that the US military was completely and utterly defeated. Completely untrue. The US, South Vietnam, and the rest of their allies killed what is estimated to be almost 1.2 million. The US lost 58,159. Total deaths for all of America + allies totaled out to 315,384. That's a big difference. It's pretty clear which side had the more competent military. Of course the US suffered heavy losses but they were inflicting far more damage and killing far more enemies. The military was not the reason America lost in Vietnam as you have already said. Some people can't seem to understand that Vietnam was lost for political reasons more than anything. Most foreigners do not understand what the political landscape in America was like at the time. Instead they just make ignorant assumptions about something they don't understand. Mostly to piss Americans off. We have no idea how other countries would have fared in Vietnam and that is a fact.
- 5 years ago
Dirty Skunk is absolutely correct; however, you should understand that the specific question you asked is relative and somewhat generic. Currently the United States is the only nation that can execute it's will anywhere, anytime, and for however long it wants, on the face of the planet. We are the only nation that can do any of this unilaterally - meaning we don't need any allies helping us. It also depends on what the government - and nation - are willing to accept. For example, we could reinstate the draft and maintain an Army of millions with current technology if the Country was willing to pay for it - while we would be technologically weaker if we merely maintained current levels, we would still be superior to everyone else for a long time. But that scenario is just no realistic. Even if we get "weaker", we are still superior to everyone else on the planet by a huge order of magnitude. We would have to get weaker by 25 or more percent to even seriously have a degradation in capability - and we would still be the only real super power. The United States will loose it's place int he sun eventually, but it will be a couple of generations off before it is even a concern.
- 1 decade ago
based on the number of naval vessels, aircraft, spending and overall population USA has the greatest military in the world by a large margin. They USN has a larger tonnage than the next 13 combined. Having 11 aircraft carriers and 1 being built all of which are supercarriers (the largest warships ever built) that means there's 1 super carrier in the USN for every foreign carrier (super and normal). At this moment the UK is building 2 and France is building only one suppercarrier. The USA is also first in aircraft number and technology having 18,169 active aerial-based weapons compared to the next largest Russia having only 3,888. The USA also spends $515,400,000,000 annually for military budgets. France now being the second only spends $61,571,330,000 right above China's $59,000,000,000. However China does have the largest manpower in the world with 729,323,673 available military manpower. The USA is 3rd on available manpower with 144,354,117.
- 6 years ago
Honestly people are stupid for thinking that the US has a weak army.
USAvsChina. We can draft a 100million people. They can Draft 700million people. LOST! In away. Maybe. If they invaded us we would be in for the fight of our lives. We invade them. Impossible.
USAVSUK Very hard fight. US would probally be at war with England, France, Germany, And Spain. If they all pull together we have a hard fight on our hands
USAvsFrance. Still another hard fight. The French are not cowards. How I know. I am one. Again only way for France is with allies.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- 1 decade ago
Most of the leadership in Japan has the same opinion of us in WW2 just weeks before we erased 2 of their major cities off the map in the blink of an eye...
Vietnam? We won all of the battles, but lost the war (due to poor moral stateside). The death toll speaks for itself...
Afghanistan? at the rate they're going, we won't need to win... If they keep strapping bombs to themselves and their children's chests, they'll drive themselves into extinction. Osama? he's probably already dead, splattered all over the inside of some cave like spagetti and meatballs (those thermo-barics leave quite a mess..). We'll never be able to confirm or deny it as he has too many lookalikes.
Iraq? Saddam thought we were weak in desert storm, we wiped out the majority of his supposed "invincible army" in a matter of weeks. He didn't learn his lesson then, and eventually found himself at the end of a rope. As for everyone else, they're in the same boat as Afghanistan (negative population growth)
The United States is the youngest of all countries, and in it's time has become the richest, most advanced country in the world. We have the most powerful, technologically advanced military in the world. We practically invented modern firearms (John Maxim, John Browning, Sam Colt, Eugene Stoner, etc.), Invented mass production, the automobile, etc. Were the first in flight, first to build nuclear weapons, and the only country to put a man on the moon.
And we're weak? Anyone who thinks so is an Idiot in every sense of the word....
Source(s): Common Sense - Mr. WizardLv 71 decade ago
Our history's brilliant military leaders had something that today's military leaders ( and this includes the President, by the way ) are clearly missing....BALLS---and the brains to use them!! Our military ranks are rife with brown-nosing, inept people--who are so busy putting affronts as if they KNOW what to do when they don't. And when they snag a promotion---it's done at great risk to scores of OUR military troops. Yes, office politics in the U.S. military CAN be dangerous.
And the installation of political correctness in the military sure has NOT helped matters much, either.
When you face a sly dirty combative enemy---then YOU too must match that enemy in combat by being just as sly....and just as dirty!! When WE accept that lesson and put it to use---maybe THEN we'll regain the world's full respect.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Very true about Vietnam. Whenever a country's own citizens don't support the war, they often lose, like Britain and the American Revolution. I blame liberals for all of America's problems....Damn hippies.
- Desert RogueLv 51 decade ago
You are right about everything except USA vs. Russia, Russia is so broke they cant even pay the troops the russian air force hardly flies any combat plane because they cant afford the fuel
Russia would fall in less than a year as would China.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Weak? What are you talking about. Our military is definitley not weak, as for the poor planning and decisions the brass make - yes I guess you could say that is weak.
- NathanSensationLv 51 decade ago
easy
Its because they are jealous of our freedom. If they can't have their own happiness living in a strong country (not perfect but strong) they lash out to reduce your own pride so you feel as low as they do.
Just ignore them. If they come to your door threatening you, drop a 2,000lb bomb on their entire family.