Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

How can Harry Potter be such a FREAK?

Look, this really frustrated me when i read the middle names of Harry Potter's children. One is Albus Severus Potter which seems complete justice with the two former Head Masters. The other one is James Sirius Potter which is also good job done by him to pay tribute to his father and his best friend.But, his foolishness and his carelessness lies with the third child-i.e Lily LUNA Potter. How in the world did he forget the sacrifices of Remus Lupin and Alastor Moody? Luna Lovegood is after all still alive and even Hermione and Ron didn't make their childrn's name aer those two heroes. That is very bad, Rowling should have considered it. What are your opinions????

10 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    First off, don't call Harry a freak. I'd kill you if you said that to me in person.

    Anyways, would you name your daughter Lily Lupin Potter? Or Lily Alastor Potter? Or even worse, Lily Moody Potter?

    Honestly, the names had to make sense, didn't they? Harry didn't forget about the sacrifices that Moody and Lupin made. But naming your kids after them isn't the only way to pay a tribute. A memory is enough.

    How you think it's foolish and careless that Harry didn't name his daughter after men is completely beyond my understanding. I'm sure he told his kids about Lupin, Moody, and anyone else who passed away.

    Relax. You're over-analyzing.

  • 1 decade ago

    Luna might also be a tribute to Lupin?

    Luna = moon

    Lupin = wolf

    Lupin was a werewolf, so was kinda a wolf by moon, in a way.

    And people can only have so many names, they wouldn't all fit, unless of course Harry and Ginny started breeding like bunnies, they wouldn't have enough to give each kid the names of two heroes. They only had the three children, after all.

  • 4 years ago

    i don't see what the massive deal is. all of us has their very own evaluations. merely like the type you do with regards to the twillight series. you do unlike those books and human beings does not like Harry Potter. If all of us in this international could like a similar component, it can be a run of the mill place, does not it? you like Harry Potter and that i think of it may be bizarre if you acquire battling mad approximately what somebody says, yet once you're merely debating and telling your opinion, it style of feels completely usual. :) And no, you at the instant are not a psychological case... i could say it rather is a hundred% usual, because of fact all of us has their very own evaluations!! :) So keep on protecting it, sweetie. that's all stable. P.S. i hit upon that outstanding that books affected you in this manner of helpful way. Yeah, you are able to had gaining wisdom of problems at school, yet with the help of the type you type and do your grammar, you sound rather sensible to me. I want you the main suitable and keep on examining. that's going to purely make you smarter. i admire figuring out on up a e book and going into yet another international.. :)

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I am pretty sure it is because it was a girl. That would be my best guess.

    But I think Harry and Luna had a really sweet friendship. Almost one that you can't forget. I think in a sense her originality became part of him because he cared about her as a friend. She stood out to him.

    Ginny also loved Luna as a friend. She stood up for her, and really got to know her well.

    I am sure they would use the other names if they had another boy.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    she was big party we just didn't read about it.while ron ,hermione, and harry were out in the wood and stuff (in the last book) neville and luna keeped DA running. and in the last battle alot of the kids that were in it fought with them. so she did a lot and should be in the name.

  • 1 decade ago

    i guess he just didn't want to give his little girl a boy's name for a middle name.

    plus, don't you think that teddy lupin would want to name a kid remus, after his father?

    because for a while i thought that ron and hermione should have named their son fred, but then i realized that george probably had dibs on that name. teddy has dibs on remus.

    and harry wasn't super close with moody. he knew impostor moody better than the real moody. lol. now, i'm not saying that moody didn't sacrifice for harry, because he did, but moody wasn't really important in harry's life.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    You wanted him to name a girl after a couple of men? That WOULD be freaky. Luna was a heroine, and JK Rowling knew exactly what she was doing.

  • 1 decade ago

    Maybe it shoul've been Nymphadora...but not Remus or Alastor for Lily...

  • .
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    Maybe Ginny named their third kid? Blame Ginny, lol

    Love those two!! =)

  • Are you serious?

    wtf.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.