Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

What's with baby yogurt?

I've been feeding my baby normal yogurt for months. He likes it with fruit puree mixed in or just a bit of juice, and even just straight.

But I keep seeing the baby yogurt on the shelf at the grocery store. I'm suspicious of it--it doesn't need refrigerated, apparently, which means it's full of preservatives, and is probably loaded with sugar and artificial colors.

But my "hey, am I doing this mom thing right?" alarm keeps buzzing at me. Is there any *real* reason normal grown-up yogurt from the dairy section is bad for my baby? Or is this baby yogurt just a marketing ploy? He's almost 1, and like I said, has been eating yog for a while now.

Update:

Our pediatrician listed yogurt pretty early in his "new foods" schedule. I think that because it's cooked, or because of the active cultures it's easier to digest than milk.

Update 2:

We buy plain yogurt and add straight fruit. We only get flavored yogurt if we're out and about and he needs something to eat. I'm not worried about the sugar.

The non-refrigerated stuff still has more ingredients than the normal stuff. I definitely prefer shorter ingredients lists.

Update 3:

rache_ole: Are the serving sizes the same? Sugar per serving comparisons only work if the serving sizes are the same, which I doubt.

6 Answers

Relevance
  • ?
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Baby yogurt comes in smaller servings, which is why it has less sugar. The Dannon comparison in the other answer ignores the fact that the Dannon serving is almost twice as large.

    Some baby yogurt is hyperpasteurized, so it does not need refrigeration. (In Europe, you can get hyperpasteurized adult yogurt, but adults are needlessly suspicious of anything that does not need refrigeration.) Hyperpasteurization is completely fine, and it doesn't hurt the yogurt or your baby in any way. As is done with milk, the yogurt is heated to kill the bacteria in it. Hyperpasteurization just heats it for a little longer. With the bacteria killed, you don't need refridgeration. The same thing is done in canning food.

    If you prefer a shorter ingredient list, go for that. I looked at Dannon all-natural (adult) yogurt, Yo baby, and Gerber yogurt. The ingredients, not surprisingly, are almost identical. If you think "naturally milled organic sugar" is somehow different from "sugar", then go that way. Neither of them contain "lead paint chips", which is what you should worry about your baby eating.

  • 1 decade ago

    The unrefrigerated baby yogurt is NOT packed with preservatives, sugars OR artificial colors. Adult yogurt, though, IS packed with way more sugar than you will find in baby yogurt.

    Gerber NON-refrigerated yogurt contains the following:

    CULTURED WHOLE MILK, SUGAR, BANANA PUREE, TAPIOCA STARCH NONFAT DRY MILK, CITRUS PECTIN, GELATIN, CITRIC ACID, NATURAL BANANA FLAVOR, BANANA JUICE CONCENTRATE, TURMERIC EXTRACT COLOR

    and has 11 g. of sugar per serving...

    now this is Dannon ALL NATURAL, VANILLA yogurt (25 GRAMS OF SUGAR PER SERVING!)

    % DV*

    Calories 150

    Calories from Fat 25

    Total Fat 2.5g 4%

    Saturated Fat 1.5g 8%

    Trans Fat 0g

    Cholesterol 10mg 3%

    Sodium 100mg 4%

    Potassium 330mg 9%

    Total Carbohydrates 25g 8%

    Dietary Fiber 0g 0%

    Sugars 25g

    Protein 7g 14%

    Vitamin A 0%

    Vitamin C 2%

    Thiamin (Vitamin B1) 6%

    Riboflavin 25%

    Vitamin B6 6%

    Vitamin B12 15%

    Biotin 0%

    Iron 0%

    Vitamin D 0%

    Calcium 25%

    Phosphorus 20%

    Magnesium 6%

    Pantothenic Acid 8%

    Zinc 6%

    Selenium 0%

    *%DV means % Daily Value based on a 2000-calorie diet

    Ingredients:

    Cultured grade A reduced fat milk, sugar, natural vanilla flavor, pectin. Contains active yogurt cultures including L. acidophilus.

    EDIT*** However, it is still better to buy the refrigerated Yo-Baby yogurt as it is made from whole milk, has no artificial ANYTHING, and has way less sugar than adult yogurt.

    EDIT 2** The Gerber website does not say how many grams there are per serving, but the YoBaby yogurt website does, and that yogurt has 12 g. of sugar per serving, so it's pretty similar.

    YoBaby has 12 g. of sugar per serving (113g)

    Dannon ALL natural has 25 g of sugar per (170g)

    So for ever 6.8g of dannon you are feeding your baby they are ingesting 1 g of sugar.

    Where-as a baby has to eat 9.4 g of YoBaby yogurt to ingest 1 g of sugar.

  • 1 decade ago

    I fed my son normal yogurt, too. I don't see any reason to avoid normal yogurt unless your pediatrician wants your child to avoid dairy. I'm not familiar with the baby yogurt that's on the shelf -- maybe it's dairy free? Some pediatricians say you should hold off on introducing dairy until your baby is 1 year old.

  • daa
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Marketing ploy. We usually buy plain yogurt (ingredients: milk, active cultures.) and add fresh fruit. When we need portable yogurt, I buy Brown Cow or Chobani flavored yogurts, which have fewer additives and less sugar than others.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • jlb
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Un-refrigerated yogurt? Ew.

    My 15 month old has only ever had normal yogurt (usually greek style) and occasionally that yo-baby stuff b/c it is the only whole milk yogurt I can find.

  • 1 decade ago

    They say babies are not supposed to have real milk products like yogurt etc until after they are 1 due to milk allergies. All I have seen is those products are more expensive and smaller. Examples: They have cereal grain fruit bars just like nutri-grain, cheese crackers just like goldfish or cheese nips, fruit snacks as well. I look at the ingredients and then make the call.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.