Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Why are people in America so afraid of Communism?

I'm not USA citizen, and searching in Yahoo Answers I've noticed people tends to be quite of an ignorant on issues regarding communism. They somewhat tend to believe that communism is directly relationed with a dictatorial government, which would cause them to lose their so called "Freedoms". They also don't understand the difference between an economic system (IK Capitalism, Communism) with a Government system (Democracy, Dictatorship, and others).

They even use Communism as some kind of insult. No, it's not an insult. It's more like the sum of all the worst things a person can be.. ever! (Communist = Terrorist, Killer, Thief, Pervy, Homophobic, Dictator, and others).

And what scares me the most, is that most people is very critic to communist while they haven't even read Marx nor the "Communist Manifesto" which does explain the basics of a communism system.

What do you think about it? Why is this prejudice caused? Why do they speak about it when they remain ignorant about the issue? Why do they actually believe Stalin was communist? Don't they understand the basics of communism?

I would prefer polite answers! But do as you please :)

Update:

*Dear Andrew. I noticed you are quite informed but still -"Americans can't name a Communist country that is not or was not run by a corrupt, dictatorial government"- because obviously there haven't been none. Or are you pretending to say that the URSS was communist?

I do not agree with you either on the second point. I don't think it's in human nature to look for it own good even if he has to smash the heads of other individuals (which is the basis of capitalist system). I do think we, who are accostumed to this sytem, tend to think it's only way to be.

Update 2:

** Boriqua. I'll quote you: "The American dream is to have a house, a family, and a job to support your family. The Communist dream is to have a working government and country while you may live in the streets working to do this." NOT TRUE. Basic concepts of communism means we'll have the American dream. There would not be rich people, I agree with you with that. But still, if all things you'll have them for granted. Don't you think you'd be happy?

Update 3:

***Adam Adam. I'm afraid to say that you're right. But still, what revolutionary concept in human history hasn't been forced at "gunpoint". Even the Capitalist system did, and does still by the opression of the poor, get founded by the killing and suffer of many. Remember all those fenchs killed in the XIII century? Or the english that were stripped from they lands to work on factories? Even the USA independence was founded over the killing of both English and American people.

I don't think either communist is the master plan. Nor do I think there is one at all. I was just considering why people is so scared about it, when it's quite obvious that it doesn't even exist.

Update 4:

***Adam Adam. I'm afraid to say that you're right. But still, what revolutionary concept in human history hasn't been forced at "gunpoint". Even the Capitalist system did, and does still by the opression of the poor, get founded by the killing and suffer of many. Remember all those fenchs killed in the XIII century? Or the english that were stripped from they lands to work on factories? Even the USA independence was founded over the killing of both English and American people.

I don't think either communist is the master plan. Nor do I think there is one at all. I was just considering why people is so scared about it, when it's quite obvious that it doesn't even exist.

Update 5:

**** "....." Sorry for that (URSS). English is not my mother language and those are the letters we use here. Instead of USSR (Union of Soviet Socialist Republics) we use URSS (Union de Republicas Socialistas Sovieticas).

I do think Democracy is the way. Problem is that, under a Capitalist system, Democracy is as unreal as Communism was for USSR and Cuba. People just THINK they live under Democracy, but they do not. Even the word "DEMOCRACY" which comes from "demos" people and "kratos" government, would mean a "Government of the people"... which kind of reminds me something... yes, communism

9 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    1) Cold war, history sticks with people for a long time.

    2) Democratic and Republic countries prevail far further and far more often then any Communistic country has (Refer to Cold War)

    3) We are afraid of corruption in our own government, which is said to be "Controlled" by the working class, and with that we are afraid of what would happen is Communism took over via more "corruption"

    These are same basic hunches and ideas to help you out, I rather not get to in depth with this.

    4) Communism tells us to share everything we have. Sharing is hard for humans to do. Sharing everything is impossible.

    5) Communism eliminates the dream of one day becoming rich.

    6) The American dream is to have a house, a family, and a job to support your family.

    The Communist dream is to have a working government and country while you may live in the streets working to do this.

    It mostly comes out to Moral Balance vs Human Balance

    The Rumor that we were taught to be afraid of Communism, even though we mentally pick up that fear in our teaching and what we see.

    It also comes out to triumphs vs losses and how much gained/lossed.

    When Russias communism collapsed people were tearing down statues and drawing pictures of the old Anarchy that was assassinated, and creating books about capitalism, their once feared enemy.

    Here's something you should do, ask a Communist why they fear Capitalism so much.

  • 1 decade ago

    Under Marx concept a strong central government was to be created to gather together all the country's resources and redistribute them equally to everyone and then dissolve the central government. This step was to last no more than two years. The USSR stayed in this step from 1917 until 1991 and China has been stuck in this step for a long time also. The problem with Communism is that people are greedy, when they get into power they will stay there until they die. Communism is a bad idea, any government that says man is bigger than God is in trouble anyway.

  • 1 decade ago

    There are two reasons:

    1. Most Americans can't name a Communist country that is not or was not run by a corrupt, dictatorial government. In particular, the Cold War still sticks in everyone's mind, and to include a current example, China is a communist country that commits many human rights violations.

    2. Communism, as an economic system, is too far left of center in the political spectrum to gain widespread approval in America- in addition, it contradicts the "work for yourself" attitude that many people have.

    Personally, I disagree with communism on economic grounds- such a system only works well when people can actually motivate themselves to work for the common good without gaining anything else in return, which is against human nature.

  • 1 decade ago

    because of the U.S war against the USSR they demonized and bastardized communism but i belive that communism cannot succeed for this simple reason people always follow a leader and a class but also u spelled it URSS not USSR...because Lenin called it a communist government people thought that communism (when Stalin took power) was the real form of communism but it really is totalarianism but during the U.S's war against the USSR they called what they did and what they were doign was communism to tell people to fight the USSR and join the U.S as a democracy.....its just a bunch of propaganda that turned communism to what it is known as today but i fully belive in democracy but not the people in the government

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    Like miss Jay said it's leftover from the propaganda from the Cold War. They wanted people to support the war so they used any means necessary (like posters, even cartoons and movies) to unite Americans against Communist countries. It got to the point where communism became a bad word. People were accused and investigated for any hint of Communist ties, promoting a mentality where it wasn't even socially acceptable just to learn about it. So to this day people just think "bad" even though they know nothing about it. Old habits die hard I guess.

    Source(s): Life. And American history classes.
  • ?
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    communism looks good on paper. lots of things do. but in practice, results will vary. not, may vary, but will.

    communism has been forced at gunpoint and by brutal means, because its concepts can never be applied to large numbers of people. youre giving way too mcuh credit to the human race, we havent found the right way to live and govern in thousands of years, communism sure wont be the master plan.

  • 1 decade ago

    Because we were told to be afraid of it. Propaganda is a stronger vehicle than actual facts and most of us have no idea what it is.

  • Goldie
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    Because we like our freedom and biased, unbalanced society lol

    Nah I'm not American either

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I think communism would be good if we dint have such money hungry politicians

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.