Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Fellow atheists: quick question regarding your entertainment choices?

I'm sure someone out there can spin this into "OMG see you're really searching for teh lordz!", but I'm asking purely out of curiosity:

Do you guys find yourselves drawn towards, or pushed away from, certain stories (books, movies, television shows, etc) because of religious content?

I ask because in looking over my list of favorite shows, they're stuffed to the gills with religion in some form or another. Carnivale (short run on HBO, pretty much "What if the kinds of stories that were told in the Bible were still happening" set in the Dustbowl during the Great Depression), Battlestar Galactica (religion all over the place), LOST (religious allegory), Haibane Renmei (never fully explained, but the best interpretation I've seen is angels in limbo), etc.

So, yeah. That's all. Religion in entertainment - a turn-on? A turn-off? Neither?

Update:

EDIT: "I think you are projecting this idea onto us (well me). I don't ming science fiction or even fantasy as a tool to IMAGINE one idea or another but the ideas do not need to be religious ideas."

Not sure I follow, but I think you're asking if I'm reading religion into them, rather than their actually being religious. I'd argue that the four mentioned are blatantly religious, no reading into required.

BSG - The Cylons believe in the one true God, humans are polytheistic, ancient prophecies in religious texts, and the entire original series drew heavily from the Mormon faith.

LOST - Not obvious at the beginning, but about the time you get Jacob and Esau (dressed in white and black) wagering over the souls of mankind, it's kind of obvious.

Carnivale - A healer as the 'chosen' avatar for Good, a preacher 'chosen' as the avatar for Evil, set during a religious revival during the Great Depression.

Haibane Renmei - The entire cast is people with halos and wings, set somewhere after d

13 Answers

Relevance
  • 10 years ago

    The only show on your list that I've watched is BSG, and I didn't really care for the religious angle. Most of the shows I watch for entertainment are pure fantasy, horror, or SciFi: Dr. Who, Merlin, Dexter, True Blood, MI-5, Lie to Me, Castle. I also like non-fiction shows like Mythbusters, How It's Made, Good Eats, America's Test Kitchen, The Universe, Build It Bigger. So out of this TV realm, I'd say I'm certainly not drawn to religious content in shows, and possibly turned off by it. Or maybe the types of entertainment I like typically doesn't have religion as an explicit theme. For movies I typically stick to horror/suspense, scifi, and blockbuster action. A big part of my entertainment hours is computer/video games and those seldom have religion as a main focus on the story, although the first 3 Halo games are an exception.

  • 10 years ago

    Generally a turn-off. Examples: I enjoyed Ben Hur until it got to all the Christianity stuff at the end. I absolutely hated all the Bajoran religion stuff on Deep Space 9. Or when Vulcans had a temple complete with religious relics in Star Trek: Enterprise. Or when that mystic wise-woman shows up in the middle of the first Matrix movie.

    I absolutely *adore* Jesus Christ Superstar, but that's in part because it is very agnostic-- it is very ambiguous as to whether the Jesus presented there is divine or not.

  • Anonymous
    10 years ago

    If the religious aspect is wielded with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer, then that turns me off.

    Likewise if the author is inserting religion in order to give a mediocre story a faux sense of gravitas or profundity.

    But judicious use of religion, religious imagery, religious symbolism or analogy can really enhance a story.

  • I think you are projecting this idea onto us (well me). I don't ming science fiction or even fantasy as a tool to IMAGINE one idea or another but the ideas do not need to be religious ideas. They MAY be similar but that's what I think religion is: Made up ideas presented as truths. The problem is they are usually really ancient & half baked.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • ?
    Lv 5
    10 years ago

    Usually I don't like all the religion stuff but if the show is interesting regardless the religious theme I wouldn't mind watching it. It depends on the content.

  • 10 years ago

    So long as it not overly done, I can stand just about anything in a show if it's a good show. Take High School of the Dead, it was good except for the extreme amount of fan service, it actually got annoying.

  • ?
    Lv 7
    10 years ago

    It would depend on the movie or TV show. The Passion of The Christ, The Ten Commandments ect.. movies like that i would be turned off.

    But if there are religious references in a TV show then no it will not bother me

  • 10 years ago

    Absolutely no problems with that at all.

    Most religious music however is just painful to listen to (especially on the Christian side of things, some Islamic music is pretty cool).

  • ?
    Lv 6
    10 years ago

    I'm neither attracted nor turned off by religious subtext in art and entertainment.

    Religion and it's associated archetypes are deeply embedded in historical and contemporary culture, and are often used as narrative or emotional shorthand by writers. Ditto ideas of destiny and fate. I'm capable of understanding (and being moved) by such devices while still not giving them any credence in reality; suspension of disbelief, and all that.

  • Anonymous
    10 years ago

    I don't have a problem with religious art, history, architecture or music if it's good. Some is appallingly bad.

    I love all music accept rap and some reggae.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.