Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Does an expectant mother have the right to chose the position she gives birth in?

My wife is pregnant and due in about 2 months! We have been doing research and collecting information on the whole giving birth process, and we read in a Lamaze magazine about various positions to give birth in. The magazine suggested that the traditional "lie horizontal on your back with your feet in stirrups and push against gravity" position was not ideal, and has many disadvantages.

Of the other positions we saw, and have researched and heard about, a position of lying on your side seemed to be the ideal one for us. My wife has difficulty breathing when lying on her back and does so much better on her side, and it was suggested that this position can reduce the chance for needing an episiotomy. There were several other advantages to this position, and a variant of it with her body slightly elevated seems like it would be even better.

The problem is that our doctor seems rather unwilling to allow her to give birth in any other than the traditional "lay back and stick your legs in the air" position. We tried talking to him about it, and he did say that she could be in any position she wanted for the first stage of labor (when the cervix is still dialating). But for the second stage, the actual pushing and giving birth stage (the one we are concerned about) he insists that my wife assumes the traditional position. My wife particularly finds this very unacceptable.

We thought about the idea of changing doctors, but in the birthing class today the nurses (at the same hospital as our doctor) seemed to indicate that all the doctors at our hospital keep to this practice (despite the class covering alternative birthing positions), and with our particular insurance (Medicaid) changing doctors now would be very difficult. Add to that that we live in a small community, there is only one hospital anywhere nearby and our doctor choices are very limited. Being of low income limits it further. And, aside from this one point of contention, we like our doctor.

So what rights does my wife have? How can we assert those rights? Is there anything else we can do? My wife is very uncomfortable and frustrated with this situation and I join her in at least the frustration part, but after trying to talk to our doctor once we feel somewhat helpless.

If the information is relevant, we live in Missouri (in the United States) and my wife has no other medical insurance other than state medicaid for expectant mothers. Obtaining other insurance would be completely out of our budget, as we were barely able to buy groceries this pay period, and our savings has been recently drained due to surprise expenses. What extra we will have on my next paycheck will have to go straight back into rebuilding it.

References and links are welcome, as always, as are personal experiences and knowledge. Thanks for any info in advance and God bless!

Update:

All of my experience with doctors has told me that, even when you have a good doctor, having a medical degree does not make you always right. And an expert oppinion is still an oppinion. I see no deductive, logical, or evidence based reason that "if the doctor thinks it's best, it's best". I have seen far far too many counter-examples. And I have heard far to many doctors and experts dissagree with one another. It is one of the tragedies of the medical profession - too much subjective oppinion and not enough objective reason and science.

Update 2:

One thing I do like about her doctor is that he does NOT do routine episiotomies. He only does them if absolutely necessary. However, you are right about the not eating in labor thing, although our nurses at the birthing class suggested an easy way around that was not to come to the hospital until some time through the first stage of labor, where all that's happening is the cervix dialating, that being at home during this time could be more comfortable and still safe.

Changing doctors and midwives are probably out, unless I can find one that works for free, and can somehow find a way to transport my wife, in labor, an hour or more to the next nearest hospital, or find someone willing to drive the distance to meet us. I do like the idea of hospital care - in some cases it can save lives. Midwives can't administer blood in the case of excess bleeding, as far as I know. In the land of the free and the home of the brave, I feel like we have no choices or options, except to go it alone, wh

3 Answers

Relevance
  • 10 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Perhaps you should change doctors. I always gave birth in a reclining position. Flat on your back is much harder, can cause fetal distress, and the mother is way more likely to tear in that position. Your doctor probably also does routine episiotomies, which actually cause tears.

    I used the Bradley method with my births. Perhaps a homebirth with a midwife would be even better than the care it appears you are going to get. I doubt they will even let her eat in labor. They probably expect her to fast for 24 hours or more. This can make her too weak to have the baby and need a c-sec because of not eating. I know someone personally that this happened to.

  • 10 years ago

    That is absurd. It is her body and she should listen to it. I have helped deliver babies as a registered nurse and we always encouraged the mom not to lay on her back because it isn't the most ideal position. If her doctor is so ignorant than he shouldn't be practicing. I think most moms and doctors are just accustomed to back deliveries because that is what we always see and hear about. But squating, side lying, and hands & knees positions are great!

  • 10 years ago

    If your doctor thinks that the traditional birthing position is best, then its best. You could try to persist in telling the doctor that your wife has trouble breathing when laying on her back, and he should listen if you are determined.

    Good luck!

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.