Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

?
Lv 4

How many failed religions would one need, before you finally understand why the whole idea is silly?

All the people of previous religions, believed just as much as you do now, and they had the same conviction, and determination.

But today, their God is a myth, their belief is part of stories, which in themselves are not taken up seriously. Dismissing their belief is probably not even seen as blasphemy. And over time, more and more religions shared the same fate...with the total number of religions formed totalling a couple of thousand.

So how many more do we need to create, and dismiss before you finally see our point, that they're ALL made up, and that they can ALL be dismissed in the same manner as you dismiss the other thousands of possible Gods?

Update:

@Ed - in my opinion, religion is merely a coping mechanism, helping those who do not have access to the answers, come up with their own interpretations, setting their mind at rest. I'm referring to the questions such as "Where do we come from?', and "What happens to us when we die".

Other than that, the whole principle that you need to repent to some God, pray for forgiveness etc etc is just stupid, just like you'd think praying to some sea monster with 7 tentacles is stupid, where this very act might have been exactly what another group did a couple of thousand years ago.

Update 2:

@Vanmom - so lets entertain the following thought. Lets say Islam and Christianity dies out, along with any other major religions. Lets assume that Scientology remains.

- we move on a couple of thousand years...

It's now the year 9787, and Scientology has now been practices for more than 7,000 years, thus making it the longest, and oldest ACTIVE religion. Would this then mean that it is correct, simply due to it being old?

Update 3:

@Chase Pembroke - your God couldn't even tell that the Earth he created himself, was round and not flat. Now you expect me to believe that he's going to tell me what happened before the Big Bang, and after we die?

21 Answers

Relevance
  • ?
    Lv 4
    10 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    It matters not how many religions are wrong as long as at least one is right.

    The Bible is true, and those who actually follow it are right.

  • ?
    Lv 4
    10 years ago

    Trying to use rational thought to appeal to the religious will never work. They believe in miracles and magic. They will take what is told to them by the holy man with a funny hat or robe and believe in it completely. They do not understand that Gods depend on geography. Whether you are a Christian or a Muslim depends on your birth place. Christians are Atheists about all other religions, Atheists just take it 1 god further.

    We will just have to wait out religion. With the rise of modern science and the dissemination of information via the internet, it won't be long. This will be the demise of belief in fairy tails, the superstitious and tribal myths. We just have to hope that those religious that want to bring about the end of the world because it is "supposed to happen anyway" in their particular holy book don't ever get too much power.

  • Robin
    Lv 6
    10 years ago

    Actually, those stories that are labeled myth, doesn't mean those gods aren't still worshipped. Claiming the stories are myths doesn't take away from belief in those gods. You just don't see pagans telling others they have to take those myths as Literal Absolute Fact.

    And how many failed political stances will it take before people give up on politics all together? Seems rather silly to throw everything out just because a man-made system fails, doesn't it?

    "Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater"

  • ?
    Lv 5
    10 years ago

    Judaism was the first monotheistic religion. It still hasn't faded away into oblivion and mythology.

    I don't see your point.

    The idea that other people have firmly believed and been wrong can't hurt any other belief system - the whole basis of each religion is that they are the one truth among the thousands of falsehoods. So the fact that there are thousands of falsehoods doesn't mean anything, really.

  • 10 years ago

    If a tree falls in woods and no one is there hear it, does it make a sound?

    The fact that people do "believe" in their God and it influences their choices in life not mean God exists? Even if you do not believe and there may not be a physical being (or energy), God may only exist by the results of the belief. Non existence can not create consequence. And lets face it history is load with consequences of God.

  • 10 years ago

    Another person bashing religion as primitive....

    How many politicians will you believe in? How many movements will you call new and original?

    Here's the thing, religion exists to explain the unexplainable ( what happened before the big bang, what happens after death, how could something come out of nothing[which logically is what HAD to have happened for the universe to exist] to create the big bang, which somehow caused life).

    People are looking for answers, you think you are more wise then the entirety of the human species in present and past, to say that this is ridiculous?

  • Anonymous
    10 years ago

    I only needed one religion that did not have evidence to support the claim that god exists. Once I realized they could not prove the existence of their god. I realized no religion has any support for their beliefs. Like if humanity discovered a god the evidence for it would be used to support the belief of any religion. Sense there is no evidence just makes it clear that religion is silly.

  • ?
    Lv 6
    10 years ago

    i totally agree with you

    also these previous gods are almost identical to the abrahamic mythology

    these theists are atheists in respect to 99% of all deities, they are experts at proving religions false

    why cant they turn that same critical analytical eye on their own false belief

    it is beyond belief that people in 2011 still believe in a minor desert religion from 2000 years ago, that only became popular because the romans forced the entire world to believe in it or die

    those same romans that killed jesus and threw christians to the lions

    silly is an understatement, it is pathetic

  • ?
    Lv 6
    10 years ago

    It is the One that stands the test of time, and makes it to the end that is true.

    Matthew 24:14 And this gospel of the kingdom will be preached in the whole world as a testimony to all nation, and then the end will come.

    To your reply: Wouldn't it be total coincidence that all this easy access to information(even to the most remote parts of the world) and 2012 is around the corner. entertaining the thought.

  • 10 years ago

    And how many Yahoo answers will it take before atheists realise there is more to religion than the stories?

    The sole purpose of repenting to some God (there or not) is not for God's benefit but yours! As for "Where do we come from", "What happens when we die" etc, these are still very valid questions!

    Maybe you do rot in the ground, but I'd rather rot with a clear conscience! I'm not saying atheists can't live a perfectly moral life, but religion provides a path to a moral life to those who choose to take it. You should look at religion as a perspective on life, rather than a collection of stories!

    Also: maybe God is a sea monster with 100 tentacles, doesn't make the blindest bit of difference!

  • Dante
    Lv 6
    10 years ago

    This question is just one of the thousand ways whe great revolution takes place, if ever, but things don't change just because rationality seems to impose it. Mankind gives birth to rationality as well as to blindness, and there's a precise reason for both.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.