Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

how to get my son to poo in the potty?

my son is 2 1/2 and refuses to poo in the potty. he pees, and will stay dry if i take him every hour or so, but just won't poo. i know, i know, boys take longer than girls, etc. etc. but he understands where poop is supposed to go, asks for a diaper when he needs to poop, etc, and i really think he should be doing it now. he's done it a few times (3 within the past 6 months) if i catch him in the act and set him on the potty, he puts it in reverse, and clenches up...

what can i do???????

don't harp on me for this next question, cause i'm just asking.. . for those parents who don't believe that spanking is wrong, (and i'm talking spanking, not beating) would spanking be an option, since he's outright refusing? i.e. i ask him if he needs to poo, he says 'yes'. i tell him to go in the potty, and he says 'no' and shakes his head and hands me the diaper... and i'm only considering spanking after the fact - not spanking if he won't go, but maybe a light swat if he poos in his diaper? make sense? or would that be detremental to my efforts?

any other advice or encouragement?

thx

Update:

@justme .. and then what? constantly have to rinse out poopy underwear??? i get what you're saying, but i'd rather have the poop in something i can throw away (a diaper) than all over his underwear, and have to rinse by hand before i toss it in the machine.

6 Answers

Relevance
  • ?
    Lv 5
    9 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Spanking will not help, it could make it worse. Stop putting diapers on him, if he poops his pants clean it up and make a simple statement like "Oh we poop in the toilet" Relying on diapers is only making this difficult for you and him, confusing mainly for him. Stop using diapers and yes you may have to clean up some poop but he will learn faster.

  • 9 years ago

    You are allowing it to be a power struggle and you shouldn't. Back off. When he is ready, he will start doing it. Praise him a lot when he does and say nothing when he doesn't. He probably likes having this power over you and you will lose a lot of battles with him the future if you let him have that power. The normal age for full potty training for a boy is 3 1/2. Don't push it. Why does he have to do it on YOUR timeline? Let him choose. When he poops in his diaper, take it off him, walk him to the potty. Tell him poop goes in the potty and have him throw it in there. Then you both clap and cheer. Make it a came, not a battle. Some kids get freaked out if you flush this "gift' while they are there, so flush it out of his sight, or let him flush it.

    DO NOT SPANK HIM!!!! You never punish a child for going to the bathroom, no mater where he goes.. And spanking does nothing for changing behavior. All you are teaching him is that it's okay to hit if you are bigger or in power. And what, exactly, is the line between hitting your kid and beating your kid?

  • Only
    Lv 4
    9 years ago

    I had the same problem with two of my children however girls. They refused as well so finally my husband and I came up with letting them around naked. My youngest is 3 and finally completely potty trained but we were in the same shoe up to a few months ago. I thought give it a shot since it worked with my older daughter. This way, underwear would not get soiled and have to be washed and diapers/pull-ups would not give wrong message.Luckily, it was over the summer so she ran freely my youngest, however, only on hardwood floors. Believe me she did not pee on the floor. She knew to use her potty but this way she could not poop in her underwear. It took a few days but she finally poop and with lysol quickly cleaned it up the hard wood floor. She was a little upset she could not go to some parts of the house so as a reward she was allowed to run nakie through the house. After a few more times pooping on the floor she transtioned nicely to her potty.

  • yorkie
    Lv 6
    9 years ago

    i think he is too young for a spanking.

    he would get confused and think he had been spanked for going poop.

    go to the library or bookshop and find a couple of kids stories about how big boys poop in the potty.

  • 9 years ago

    get rid of the diapers. he cant hold it in forever. when my son first got potty trained, i still put diapers on him at night and he would wait till i out a diaper on him then poop so when i ran out of diapers, that was it. he started going in the toilet. if he goes at the same time everyday, then have him sit on the toilet till he goes

  • ?
    Lv 7
    9 years ago

    stop giving him diapers, completely

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.