What else do you believe without evidence?

Theists, what else do you believe without evidence....

Ok, let's say for example, you're on a jury. The defending attorney is cross-examining the arresting officer.

Officer: That is the man we believe committed the murder.

Lawyer: Did anybody see him do it?

Officer: No, but he told us he did it.

Lawyer: So, the defendant confessed?

Officer: No, the victim told us the defendant killed him.

Lawyer: So, a dead guy TOLD you who killed him?

Officer: Don't be ridiculous... he wrote it in this book.

Lawyer: The dead guy wrote a book?

Officer: He actually inspired others to write it.

Lawyer: So who actually wrote it?

Officer: No idea, we just found it.

Lawyer: Ummm Ok, so where is the body?

Officer: Don't know.

Lawyer: You ummm... don't have a victim?

Officer: Well, not in the physical sense, but I've felt his presence.

Lawyer: So, you have no body, no weapon, no evidence that a crime was even committed, but you believe that this man is guilty of murder based on a book you found and "feeling the presence" of a victim that nobody can see???

Officer: That about sums it up.

So, would you... as a jury member, vote to convict this person? I'm just trying to get a sense of continuity.

Thanks.